Wrongful death cases are among the most emotional types of personal injury cases there are, not to mention their legal complexity in the civil justice system. Families who have lost a loved one due to another party's negligence or misconduct often seek justice through financial compensation. Typically, these cases are handled in state trial or civil courts—but what happens when a wrongful death case reaches the highest level of the judicial system? Can these types of cases reach the Supreme Court?

While most wrongful death claims are resolved long before an appeal is ever filed, there are rare situations where these cases do reach the U.S. Supreme Court or a state’s highest appellate court. When they do, it’s often because the case raises important constitutional questions, involves conflicting legal interpretations across jurisdictions, or has broader legal implications beyond the specific facts of the case.

This article explores how and why wrongful death cases may be appealed to the Supreme Court, what legal issues typically trigger such reviews, and how the appeals process works at both state and federal levels.

Understanding Wrongful Death Claims

A wrongful death claim is a civil lawsuit brought by surviving family members or the estate of a person who died due to another party’s negligent or intentional actions. These lawsuits can arise from a wide range of incidents, such as:

Each state has its own wrongful death statutes that define who can bring a claim, the types of damages recoverable, and applicable time limits (statutes of limitations). For example, in New Jersey and New York, only certain family members or a personal representative of the estate may file a wrongful death suit.

The Path from Trial Court to Supreme Court

Most wrongful death cases begin in state trial courts. If one party is not happy with the case’s outcome, they can file an appeal with the state’s intermediate appellate court. That court will review whether there were any legal errors that affected the outcome of the case. Importantly, appeals courts do not re-try the case or reassess evidence—they focus strictly on legal procedures and applications of the law.

If the appellate court’s decision is still disputed, the losing party may petition the highest court in that state—often called the state Supreme Court—to review the case. These high courts have discretionary review, meaning they choose which cases to hear. In rare circumstances, a wrongful death case may even be elevated to the U.S. Supreme Court if it involves a federal constitutional issue.

When Does the U.S. Supreme Court Hear a Wrongful Death Case?

The U.S. Supreme Court receives thousands of petitions each year but hears only a small fraction of them. For a wrongful death case to be considered, it typically must:

  • Involve a federal question, such as a constitutional right (e.g., due process or equal protection)
  • Present a conflict between federal circuit courts on a legal interpretation
  • Challenge the application of federal law, such as civil rights violations under Section 1983
  • Raise an issue of broad national importance

For example, the Supreme Court has heard wrongful death cases involving qualified immunity for law enforcement, federal preemption of state claims, and the rights of non-citizens in civil litigation. One notable case is County of Sacramento v. Lewis (1998), where the Court considered whether a police chase that led to a suspect’s death violated the Fourteenth Amendment.

State Supreme Courts and Wrongful Death Appeals

More commonly, wrongful death cases are appealed to the state Supreme Court, which serves as the final authority on interpreting that state’s civil laws. A case might be accepted for review if:

  • The legal issue has not been previously settled in the state
  • There are conflicting appellate decisions on similar facts
  • The case involves significant public policy questions

Each state has its own criteria for review, but in general, the state Supreme Court will only accept cases that have broader implications for the interpretation of state law or legal consistency.

Practical Examples of Wrongful Death Appeals

Though rare, wrongful death appeals can change the legal landscape. Consider the following examples:

  • Medical malpractice caps: In some states, wrongful death appeals have challenged statutory limits on non-economic damages, arguing they violate equal protection or access to courts.
  • Employer immunity: Families may appeal cases involving workplace deaths to clarify when employers can be sued outside workers’ compensation laws.
  • Sovereign immunity: Some wrongful death cases test whether public entities can be held liable under specific circumstances.

Call Brandon J. Broderick For Legal Help

If you’ve lost a loved one due to negligence, your legal journey may start with a wrongful death claim—but it can become much more complex if appeals are involved. At Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, we understand how emotionally difficult and legally challenging these cases can be.

Our team is committed to helping families through every phase of the process, from initial filings to appeals when necessary. We’ll guide you with compassion, clarity, and experienced legal strategy to ensure your rights are protected.

Contact us today for a free consultation and let us help you seek justice and accountability for your loss.

Still have questions?

Call now and be done