When families pursue a wrongful death lawsuit in Kentucky, one issue that often arises is whether the deceased had pre-existing medical conditions. Insurance companies and defense attorneys frequently highlight these conditions to limit compensation. For grieving families, it can feel overwhelming to navigate this argument. Still, Kentucky law allows recovery even when health issues existed before the incident that caused death. Understanding how courts evaluate these claims can help families prepare for the legal challenges ahead.
Kentucky Wrongful Death Law Overview
Kentucky law defines wrongful death as a loss of life caused by another party’s negligence, recklessness, or intentional act. The state statute allows the personal representative of the deceased’s estate to file a lawsuit seeking damages on behalf of surviving family members. Damages may include medical expenses, lost income, funeral costs, and compensation for the loss of companionship and guidance. Unlike personal injury cases, wrongful death claims in Kentucky are filed by the estate, not by individual family members, though the beneficiaries ultimately receive the award.
The Role of Pre-Existing Conditions in Kentucky Wrongful Death Cases
Pre-existing conditions often become a focal point in wrongful death litigation. Defense attorneys argue that these conditions—not the accident or negligent act—were the real cause of death. For example, if someone with a heart condition dies after a car accident, the defense might claim the heart disease was the true cause. The goal is to reduce or eliminate financial liability. However, Kentucky courts apply the principle that if negligence accelerated, worsened, or combined with a pre-existing condition to cause death, the defendant can still be held responsible.
Aggravation of Pre-Existing Conditions
One key concept in these cases is aggravation. Kentucky law recognizes that individuals often live with medical conditions, but negligent actions that accelerate the impact of those conditions can still create liability. If a workplace accident or vehicle crash worsens an existing illness and leads to premature death, the negligent party remains accountable for the loss. This ensures families are not denied justice simply because their loved one was not in perfect health.
Thin Skull Rule in Kentucky
Another guiding principle is often referred to as the “thin skull” or “eggshell plaintiff” rule. This doctrine requires defendants to take victims as they are, including any vulnerabilities. If a negligent act causes harm that is more severe because of a medical condition, the defendant cannot escape liability. In wrongful death cases, this rule prevents negligent parties from using pre-existing conditions as a complete defense. Instead, the question becomes whether the act meaningfully contributed to the death, regardless of the individual’s health history.
Proving Causation in the Presence of Pre-Existing Conditions
To succeed in a wrongful death lawsuit involving pre-existing conditions, families must demonstrate that the negligent act was a substantial factor in causing death. This does not mean the condition must be ignored, but rather that it cannot overshadow the role of the defendant’s actions.
Medical Evidence and Expert Testimony
Medical records and expert testimony are critical in establishing causation. Physicians may be asked to explain whether the incident aggravated the pre-existing condition or created a chain of events that led to death. For instance, if a person with diabetes suffers injuries in a truck accident and later dies from complications, medical experts can clarify how trauma interacted with the existing illness.
Separating Natural Progression from Negligence
Courts must distinguish between a condition’s natural progression and the contribution of negligent conduct. While defense teams argue that death would have occurred regardless of the incident, plaintiff attorneys emphasize that the event accelerated or triggered the fatal outcome. Kentucky courts evaluate these arguments carefully, weighing medical opinions, autopsy findings, and the timing of health decline following the incident.
Wrongful Death Compensation Challenges and Damages
Pre-existing conditions can complicate the damages calculation. Defense attorneys may argue for reduced compensation, suggesting that life expectancy was already limited. However, Kentucky law still allows damages when negligence shortens a person’s life, even if it would not have been decades longer.
Economic Damages
Economic damages may include medical costs, lost earnings, and funeral expenses. If the deceased was employed, defense teams may claim reduced earning potential due to health conditions. Yet courts often consider the individual’s actual work history and realistic earning capacity rather than speculative assumptions.
Non-Economic Damages
Non-economic damages such as loss of companionship and guidance are not diminished simply because of health conditions. Families lose the presence, love, and support of their loved one regardless of medical history. Kentucky courts recognize this and often uphold these categories of damages despite defense objections.
Common Defense Strategies in Kentucky Wrongful Death Cases
Insurance companies and defense attorneys employ predictable strategies when pre-existing conditions are involved.
Shifting Blame to Health Issues
The most common defense is attributing death entirely to the condition. For example, in a fatal slip and fall, the defense may argue the victim’s prior osteoporosis caused the fatal injuries rather than the fall itself.
Questioning Life Expectancy
Another tactic is minimizing damages by arguing the victim’s condition already shortened life expectancy. While actuarial tables and medical records may be introduced, courts remain cautious not to unfairly discount a life simply because of illness.
Disputing Medical Causation
Defense teams often bring in their own medical experts to dispute whether the negligent act meaningfully contributed to death. This leads to a battle of experts, making the role of credible testimony even more important for families seeking justice.
Building a Strong Wrongful Death Claim Despite Pre-Existing Conditions
Families can strengthen their wrongful death cases by anticipating defense arguments and gathering robust evidence.
Steps Families Can Take
- Ensure complete medical records are obtained and reviewed.
- Work with expert witnesses who can explain the interaction between the condition and the negligent act.
- Document the deceased’s quality of life and contributions to the family before the incident.
- Highlight how the negligence accelerated death rather than focusing solely on the condition.
Importance of Legal Representation
Because wrongful death claims with pre-existing conditions often involve complex medical and legal questions, skilled legal representation is essential. Attorneys can coordinate expert testimony, challenge defense claims, and ensure the family’s right to compensation is preserved.
Conclusion
Pre-existing conditions often complicate wrongful death lawsuits in Kentucky, but they do not prevent recovery. Courts recognize that negligent acts which aggravate or accelerate existing conditions can still be a substantial factor in causing death. While defense attorneys may attempt to minimize liability by focusing on health issues, families can counter these arguments with medical evidence, expert testimony, and thorough documentation. Kentucky law protects families’ rights to seek justice, ensuring that defendants remain accountable for the role their actions played in the untimely loss of life.
Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away
Navigating Kentucky Wrongful Death Claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced attorneys at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.
Contact us now for a free legal review.