A tort is an act that causes harm to someone else, and tort law exists so the injured person can be compensated. In New Jersey, a driver can end up with a limited right to bring that kind of claim without signing anything. If the tort-option form never comes back to the insurer, the law treats the driver as having chosen the limitation on lawsuit option, and that line on the declarations page usually gets noticed only after a crash, when the bills, missed workdays, and pain are already real.

Many drivers call this choice “limited tort,” though New Jersey’s official name is the limitation on lawsuit option, or the verbal threshold. What a car accident case here can recover depends on the injury, the medical proof, and the policy, and what follows takes each in turn, from the label on your policy to the doctor’s certification a court will expect.

Key Takeaways About New Jersey’s Limitation on Lawsuit Option

  • You can sue an at-fault driver in New Jersey under the limitation on lawsuit option, the state's version of limited tort, also called the verbal threshold.
  • To recover pain and suffering, the injury must fall into one of six categories: death, dismemberment, significant disfigurement or scarring, a displaced fracture, loss of a fetus, or a permanent injury.
  • Economic losses that PIP leaves unpaid, such as medical bills above the PIP limit, can be pursued without meeting the injury threshold.
  • A permanent injury claim needs a physician's certification based on objective clinical evidence, such as imaging.

What Does the Limitation on Lawsuit Option Mean in New Jersey?

The limitation on lawsuit option is one of two choices on a New Jersey Standard auto policy. It keeps your right to sue an at-fault driver, but it limits pain and suffering claims to injuries on a statutory list. The other choice, the no limitation on lawsuit option, keeps the right to seek pain and suffering for any injury.

The limited version is known as the verbal threshold because the statute describes the qualifying injuries in words, with no dollar amount attached. Economic losses such as medical bills and lost wages are treated separately.

The person who signs for the policy often decides for the whole household. Under the same election statute that sets the default, the named insured's choice covers:

  • The named insured.
  • A spouse who lives in the household.
  • A child of the named insured or spouse who lives in the household and is not a named insured on another auto policy.

The choice also carries over to renewal and replacement policies until the insurer receives a signed form electing the other option. A grown child still living at home and listed only on a parent's policy may be bound by a form the parent signed years ago.

How Is This Option Different From Pennsylvania’s Limited Tort System?

Limited tort and full tort are Pennsylvania insurance terms, and Pennsylvania applies a different legal test. Both states let drivers trade some pain and suffering rights for lower premiums, and both keep claims for economic losses. They part ways on how an injured person gets past the restriction.

The differences that matter most after a crash line up this way:

FeatureNew JerseyPennsylvania
Official nameLimitation on lawsuit optionLimited tort option
Test for pain and sufferingOne of six listed injury categoriesA “serious injury” standard
Exceptions tied to the at-fault driverNone listed in the threshold statuteDUI conviction or ARD, a vehicle registered in another state, no required insurance, intent to injure

Pennsylvania's exceptions do not carry over to a New Jersey claim. A New Jersey driver hit by someone later convicted of DUI still needs one of the six categories to recover pain and suffering under the limited option.

Qualifying Injury Categories and Pain and Suffering Claims

A person under the limited lawsuit option can recover pain and suffering when the injury fits at least one of six categories in New Jersey's threshold statute. In the statute's own terms, they are:

  1. Death.
  2. Dismemberment.
  3. Significant disfigurement or significant scarring.
  4. Displaced fractures.
  5. Loss of a fetus.
  6. A permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability.

Only the sixth category requires permanency. A displaced fracture qualifies as its own category, so the records need to show the break was displaced, and the plaintiff does not have to prove it is also permanent. A hairline or non-displaced fracture would need to qualify through another route, such as permanent injury.

The statute defines permanency in one sentence, and every permanent injury claim is measured against it:

“An injury shall be considered permanent when the body part or organ, or both, has not healed to function normally and will not heal to function normally with further medical treatment.”

Scarring and disfigurement do not count as permanent injuries under that definition, since they have their own category.

Meeting a category is enough. In DiProspero v. Penn, the New Jersey Supreme Court held in 2005 that the statute “does not contain a serious life impact standard,” so an injured person does not have to show the injury also upended daily life.

Can You Recover Economic Losses Without Meeting the Injury Threshold?

Economic losses do not depend on the injury threshold. The limitation on lawsuit options restricts non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, and New Jersey's no-fault system pays medical bills first through Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage, regardless of who caused the crash.

A claim against the at-fault driver can reach what PIP leaves unpaid. Amounts PIP paid or could pay are kept out of the lawsuit, and unreimbursed medical expenses above the PIP limit remain recoverable from the driver.

The Basic Policy's $15,000 PIP limit shows how that plays out. Take a driver with $23,000 in hospital and therapy bills:

  • Medical bills: $23,000
  • Paid by PIP: $15,000
  • Left unpaid: $23,000 − $15,000 = $8,000

That $8,000 can be sought from the at-fault driver without proving a threshold injury. Pain and suffering from the same crash still needs one of the six categories.

Fault can reduce either kind of award. New Jersey lowers damages by the injured person's percentage of fault and bars recovery when that share is greater than the defendant's.

What Medical Evidence May Be Needed for a Permanent Injury?

A permanent injury claim needs medical proof that meets the statutory definition, and a diagnosis or ongoing pain on its own may fall short. The threshold statute requires a physician to certify, under penalty of perjury, that the injury qualifies, based on “objective clinical evidence” from valid diagnostic tests that does not depend entirely on the patient's own report.

That certification has firm timing. It must come within 60 days after the defendant answers the complaint, from the treating physician or a board-certified physician the treating doctor referred the patient to, and a court may allow one extra period of up to 60 days for good cause.

Two sentences from hypothetical medical reports show the gap between describing pain and proving permanency:

  • “Patient reports persistent low back pain and reduced range of motion since the accident.”
  • “MRI taken three weeks after the crash shows a disc herniation at L4-L5, consistent with the patient's symptoms and still present after six months of therapy.”

The second points to imaging a court can weigh. The first rests on the patient's account and a range-of-motion test, and in Agha v. Feiner, the New Jersey Supreme Court said: “subjective tests, such as those that evaluate range of motion, will not suffice.” In that case, an MRI report of a herniated disc was the only objective proof of permanency.

An unpublished Appellate Division decision, Allen v. Kane, shows how gaps add up. The plaintiff's chiropractor relied on range-of-motion testing and his own reading of MRI films, and her deposition testimony that she had no ongoing pain from the accident undercut the claim, so the court affirmed summary judgment for the driver.

Policy Elections and Exceptions That May Affect Your Claim

Whether the verbal threshold applies, and whether a claim can go forward at all, depends on insurance details beyond the injury. These facts are worth pinning down early:

  • Whose policy covers you, and whether you are a named insured on your own policy.
  • Whether your vehicle carried the New Jersey PIP coverage the law requires.
  • Whether an out-of-state driver's insurer also does business in New Jersey.
  • Whether a government vehicle or public entity was involved.

Each one can change the rules for pain and suffering before anyone looks at an MRI.

Out-of-state drivers show how far the policy reaches. A New York driver whose insurer is authorized in New Jersey crashes on the Turnpike. Under New Jersey's Deemer Statute, that policy is treated as providing New Jersey PIP, and the named insured becomes subject to the limitation on lawsuit option.

Missing coverage can end a claim. In Odunsi v. Cooney, a 2021 Essex County trial-court decision, a New Jersey resident who drove for Uber insured his car through a Texas insurer and lacked required New Jersey PIP. The court granted summary judgment to the driver who rear-ended him under the statutory bar for uninsured drivers.

Deadlines run on their own track. A lawsuit against a private driver must be filed within two years, and a claim against a public entity needs written notice within 90 days of the accident.

Sorting out which policy controls and whether an MRI report meets the statute is a lot to ask of someone still in physical therapy. An attorney can read the declarations pages, match the imaging to the certification the statute requires, and keep both filing deadlines in view.

Frequently Asked Questions:

Does the lawsuit limitation mean I cannot file any injury claim?

Choosing the limitation on lawsuit option does not stop you from filing a claim against an at-fault driver. It restricts one kind of damages, pain and suffering, to injuries that fit New Jersey’s six categories. Medical bills PIP leaves unpaid, lost wages beyond your benefits, and other economic losses can still be pursued, subject to fault and the other driver’s coverage.

Can my household’s insurance election affect me?

Your household’s election can apply to you even if you never signed the form. When a spouse or parent is the named insured, that person’s choice covers a spouse and resident children who are not named insureds on their own auto policies. If you hold a separate policy as a named insured, your own election governs. Checking the declarations pages for every policy in the home settles which option applies.

Is a permanent injury certification required in every car accident case?

The certification is tied to pain and suffering claims under the limitation on lawsuit option. Someone with the no limitation option, or someone seeking only economic losses such as unpaid medical bills, does not need it to bring that claim. When it is required, it must come from a qualifying physician within 60 days after the defendant answers, unless a court grants extra time.

Can a herniated disc qualify for pain and suffering in New Jersey?

A herniated disc can meet New Jersey’s permanent injury category when objective evidence, such as an MRI read by a qualified physician, shows the injury has not healed and will not heal with further treatment. Ongoing pain or reduced range of motion on its own may not be enough. If you had back problems before the crash, the medical records also need to separate the new injury from the old one.

Can I change my lawsuit option after an accident?

You can change your election going forward, but the change does not reach back to a crash that has already happened. The option on your policy on the date of the accident is the one that applies to that claim. If you want broader rights for the future, the switch takes effect once your insurer receives a signed form electing the other option.

Before You Assume You Can’t Sue, Hear From Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law

Choosing the limited option on your policy did not take away your right to bring a claim, and Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, can help you see which parts of your losses may still be within reach.

In a first conversation, we can go over:

  • Whether your injury fits one of New Jersey’s six categories.
  • Which medical bills PIP left unpaid.
  • Whose policy election applies to you.

Contact our team, and you’ll know which losses you may still pursue.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult an attorney for advice regarding your specific situation.

Still have questions?

Speak to an attorney today

Call now and be done