Workers’ compensation in Ohio is designed to protect employees injured on the job, but not every injury qualifies for benefits. Understanding which injuries fall outside the system’s protection is essential for managing expectations and exploring alternative legal options.
Injuries Caused by Employee Misconduct
Ohio workers’ compensation does not cover injuries resulting from an employee’s intentional misconduct or violation of workplace policies. For example, if a worker is injured while fighting, engaging in horseplay, or willfully disregarding safety procedures, their claim may be denied.
Examples of misconduct-related exclusions include:
- Getting hurt during an unauthorized or dangerous activity
- Injuries while under the influence of drugs or alcohol
- Accidents occurring during criminal acts on the job site
Employers can use drug and alcohol testing or witness accounts to contest a claim if misconduct is suspected.
Self-Inflicted Injuries
If an injury is proven to be self-inflicted—whether intentionally or through deliberate reckless behavior—it will not be eligible for workers' comp benefits in Ohio. This rule is rooted in the idea that compensation is reserved for accidents, not harm that an employee knowingly caused.
This category includes:
- Suicide or attempted suicide not linked to a compensable psychological condition
- Injuries arising from personal risk-taking behaviors not related to work duties
Injuries Outside the Scope of Employment
To qualify for benefits, the injury must occur within the scope and course of employment. If an employee is injured during activities unrelated to their job, coverage may be denied.
Common scenarios not covered:
- Commuting to or from work (with limited exceptions such as travel for a work-related purpose)
- Injuries sustained during lunch breaks off-site
- Personal errands run during work hours unless approved by the employer
Even if an employee is technically "on the clock," workers’ comp may still deny coverage if the task was not work-related.
Psychological Injuries Without Physical Harm
Ohio has strict standards for mental health claims under workers’ compensation. Generally, psychological or emotional injuries must stem from a physical injury sustained on the job to be compensable.
Not covered:
- Stress, anxiety, or depression unrelated to a physical injury
- Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) not linked to a work-related physical event
Some first responders are granted an exception under specific statutes, but most workers cannot claim compensation for purely mental conditions.
Pre-Existing Conditions Unrelated to Work
A pre-existing condition that is aggravated by job duties may qualify for workers’ comp, but if the condition worsens independently of any workplace activity, benefits are typically denied.
For example:
- An employee with chronic back pain who suffers a flare-up at home unrelated to work
- Conditions like arthritis or degenerative disc disease that progress naturally over time without work influence
However, if a workplace incident clearly accelerates the condition, a claim may be viable.
Injuries Occurring During Unauthorized Activities
Workers who step outside their job duties—known legally as a “frolic”—can lose eligibility for compensation. Ohio law differentiates between minor deviations and significant departures from assigned work.
Injuries may be denied if:
- The worker was engaging in an activity far outside their job responsibilities
- They were in an unauthorized area without a legitimate work-related reason
- The act was a personal mission that had no connection to their employer
These claims often hinge on witness testimony, surveillance, or documentation of job duties.
Independent Contractor Injuries
Ohio law typically excludes independent contractors from workers’ compensation coverage unless they are misclassified and meet legal criteria to be considered employees. Many gig workers and freelancers are surprised to find they have no recourse under Ohio’s system.
Indicators of contractor status:
- Control over their work schedule and methods
- Use of personal tools and equipment
- Working for multiple clients
If misclassification is suspected, it may be necessary to file a complaint with the Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation (BWC) or consult legal counsel.
Injuries from Voluntary Recreational Activities
Workers injured during optional company events—like a softball game or holiday party—are generally not covered by workers’ comp unless attendance was mandatory or implicitly expected.
The gray area comes in when:
- Participation is strongly encouraged by management
- Employees feel pressured to attend for career advancement
- The event takes place during paid work hours
Unless clear evidence shows the activity was work-related, such injuries are unlikely to result in benefits.
Conclusion
While Ohio’s workers’ compensation system provides important protection for injured employees, it does not guarantee coverage for every workplace incident. Claims may be denied due to misconduct, non-work-related activities, or injuries falling outside statutory guidelines. Understanding these exclusions can help workers navigate their rights and, when appropriate, seek compensation through other legal channels.
Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away
Navigating Ohio Workers Compensation claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.
Contact us now for a free legal review.