When a family loses a loved one due to someone else's negligence or wrongdoing, the financial impact can be devastating. One of the key components in a wrongful death claim is the compensation for lost income—earnings the deceased would have contributed to the household if not for the untimely death. Proving this loss is a complex but essential task to ensure fair compensation for the surviving family members. Here’s a detailed look at the steps involved in establishing a lost income claim in wrongful death cases.

Establish the Decedent’s Work History and Income

The foundation of a lost income claim starts with clear documentation of the deceased’s employment and earning capacity. Key steps include:

• Collect Employment Records: Gather pay stubs, tax returns, W-2s, and employment contracts to show consistent income over time.
• Review Employment Benefits: Consider contributions to retirement accounts, bonuses, commissions, and fringe benefits like health insurance or stock options.
• Calculate Historical Earnings: Establish an average income over the past several years to create a baseline for future projections.

This evidence paints a comprehensive picture of what the decedent’s financial contributions looked like before the accident.

Project Future Earnings and Career Growth

Lost income claims aren’t limited to past earnings. They also factor in the decedent’s projected future income, which is often where disputes arise. This requires a realistic assessment based on:

• Career Trajectory: Review the decedent’s age, education, experience, and career path to estimate potential promotions, raises, or career changes.
• Economic Conditions: Factor in the broader economic outlook, industry trends, and job market stability that could have influenced earning potential.
• Expert Testimony: Financial experts or forensic economists can provide detailed projections based on employment data, economic forecasts, and actuarial tables.

These projections should be grounded in credible evidence to withstand scrutiny from insurance companies and defense attorneys.

Include Lost Household Contributions

Income isn’t just about wages. In wrongful death cases, the value of non-wage contributions—such as childcare, housekeeping, and elder care provided by the deceased—should also be accounted for. For instance:

• Document Services Provided: Estimate the hours per week the decedent spent on domestic responsibilities.
• Determine Replacement Costs: Use local rates for services like childcare, cleaning, or elder care to quantify the financial value of these contributions.

Courts recognize these contributions as part of the overall economic loss to the family, especially when the decedent was a stay-at-home parent or provided significant caregiving.

Address Taxes and Deductions

Gross income doesn’t tell the whole story. Courts typically require that lost income calculations reflect net income, considering:

• Taxes and Mandatory Deductions: Subtract income taxes, Social Security contributions, Medicare, and other required deductions from gross earnings.
• Voluntary Contributions: Exclude voluntary deductions like 401(k) contributions or health savings accounts, unless the family can show they directly benefited.

By focusing on net income, the claim provides a more accurate picture of the actual financial loss.

Use Reliable Documentation and Expert Support

Building a strong lost income claim means relying on solid evidence and expert input:

• Financial Documentation: Maintain organized records, including pay stubs, tax filings, employment contracts, and benefits statements.
• Expert Witnesses: Economists or vocational experts can strengthen the claim by providing unbiased assessments of potential earnings and contributions.
• Detailed Calculations: Present clear, precise calculations showing the progression from historical earnings to future projections and household contributions.

This thorough approach helps counter defense arguments aimed at minimizing the claim’s value.

Account for Life Expectancy and Work-Life Balance

Courts also consider how long the decedent was expected to work and live. Factors to evaluate include:

• Life Expectancy Tables: Reference actuarial tables that consider age, gender, and health history.
• Retirement Age: Establish the likely retirement age based on the decedent’s profession and industry norms.
• Work-Life Balance Considerations: Account for possible part-time work, sabbaticals, or periods of unemployment when estimating future earnings.

By acknowledging these variables, the claim becomes more credible and reflects a balanced view of the decedent’s potential income.

Prepare for Challenges from the Defense

Insurance companies and defense attorneys often contest lost income claims by:

• Questioning Future Projections: Arguing that the estimates are overly optimistic or speculative.
• Highlighting Health Issues or Job Instability: Suggesting the decedent might not have maintained stable employment.
• Disputing Non-Wage Contributions: Minimizing the financial value of household services.

Anticipating these tactics and preparing counterarguments supported by data and expert testimony can strengthen the claim’s credibility.

Conclusion

Proving lost income in a wrongful death claim requires meticulous documentation, realistic projections, and expert support. By clearly showing the financial contributions the decedent made and would have continued to make, surviving family members can secure fair compensation for their profound loss. This process not only addresses the immediate financial impact but also honors the lasting contributions of a loved one whose life was cut short.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating Wrongful Death Claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.

Contact us now for a free legal review.