Courts in many states treat the loss of household services, meaning work you can no longer do around the home because of an injury, as an economic loss. That includes cleaning, cooking, laundry, yard work, home repairs, childcare, and running the household. The loss is usually measured by the reasonable cost of having someone else do those tasks for as long as your injury keeps you from doing them. The rules differ on one important aspect: whether you can recover for help family members gave you for free. Some courts value the services themselves and have allowed recovery for care relatives provided for free. New York, by contrast, limits past household services to expenses actually incurred and allows future services only when someone is reasonably certain to need them.

Before an injury, most of this work happens without anyone thinking about it. Afterward, a broken leg, a back injury, or a brain injury can turn laundry, groceries, and a mowed lawn into tasks someone else has to take on or pay for.

Household services are one of the less visible losses in a personal injury claim, and demand letters often overlook them. Medical bills and lost wages come with paperwork. Lost household work usually has to be documented and valued on purpose.

What Counts as Household Services in a Personal Injury Claim?

Household services are the unpaid work a person regularly does to keep a home running. When an injury takes that work away, the household loses something with a real market price, because the same tasks can be hired out.

These losses belong with economic damages in a personal injury claim, alongside medical expenses and lost income. They are separate from non-economic damages such as pain and suffering, which compensate for the experience of the injury rather than a measurable cost.

They are also different from loss of earning capacity, which addresses the paid work you can no longer do. A person who cannot return to a job and can no longer keep up a house may have both losses, and each is valued separately. Household services matter just as much for people who were not working outside the home before the injury, since the loss does not depend on a paycheck.

Which Household Tasks Can Be Assigned a Dollar Value?

Most tasks that have a market price can be valued if two things are true: you did them regularly before the injury, and your injury now prevents you from doing some or all of them.

Typical categories include:

  • Housework: Cleaning, vacuuming, laundry, and changing beds.
  • Meals: Grocery shopping, cooking, and kitchen cleanup.
  • Outdoor work: Mowing, raking, snow removal, and gardening.
  • Home maintenance: Painting, minor repairs, and seasonal upkeep.
  • Vehicle care: Routine maintenance and errands that depend on driving.
  • Caregiving: Childcare, school pickups, and help for a family member living in the home.
  • Household management: Paying bills, scheduling appointments, and coordinating repairs.

The key is the connection between the task and the injury. A lifting restriction explains why you can no longer carry laundry or groceries. It does not explain why you stopped paying bills. Claims built around tasks your restrictions actually rule out hold up better than a long list of everything a household needs.

Do You Have to Pay Someone to Recover These Damages?

It depends on the state and on whether the loss is in the past or the future.

Some states focus on what your services were worth. California's pattern jury instruction, for example, asks jurors to award the reasonable value of the household services the injured person would have been reasonably certain to provide had the injury not occurred. It does not say the replacement help must have been purchased, and courts in some states have allowed injured people to recover the value of care relatives provided for free.

New York takes a narrower view. In Schultz v. Harrison Radiator Division, General Motors Corp., decided in 1997, the plaintiff relied on free help from friends and relatives after his injury. The Court of Appeals rejected the award for past household services because he had not incurred any actual expenses. The court also held that future household-service damages are recoverable only for replacement services reasonably certain to be needed and paid for because of the injury.

Two practical points follow. First, receipts from paid help such as housekeepers, lawn services, and sitters document what you actually spent, so keep them. To recover those expenses, you must also show that the services were needed because of your injury and that the amount claimed is reasonable under the law governing your claim. Second, future household-service damages may also be recoverable, but the requirements depend on the state. In New York, the expected expenses must be reasonably certain to occur and necessary due to the injury. Other states, including California, allow claims based on the reasonable value of household services the injured person would have provided.

A spouse may also have a separate claim. A loss of consortium claim addresses the loss of a relationship's benefits, which can include companionship and assistance with everyday household activities. This claim is different from the injured person's economic damages for lost household services. States determine who can bring a consortium claim and what damages it covers, but the same loss cannot be compensated twice.

Proving You Can No Longer Do the Work

Insurance carriers may argue that family members can absorb the work or that the requested help goes beyond what the injury requires. The answer is evidence that ties specific restrictions to specific tasks.

  1. Medical restrictions in writing. Treating providers should record limits such as lifting caps, standing time, or driving restrictions. Medical records are more useful when they clearly state what you cannot do, not just your diagnosis.
  2. Functional capacity evaluations. A formal evaluation by a physical or occupational therapist can measure what your body can and cannot handle.
  3. A before-and-after log. Please write down which tasks you handled before the injury, roughly how many hours each took, and what you can manage now.
  4. Receipts and invoices. Keep every bill for cleaning, yard care, childcare, or repairs you paid for because of the injury.
  5. Statements from the household. Family members can describe who did what before the injury and how the work has shifted since.

How Lost Household Services Are Calculated

The basic math is hours multiplied by a rate. The hours come from your pre-injury routine, adjusted for what your restrictions now prevent. The rate is what it would cost to hire someone in your area for each type of work. Cleaning, lawn care, and childcare are valued at their own market rates rather than a single blended figure.

Your own routine matters more than averages, but federal time-use data shows how much of daily life this work takes up. In 2025, 87 percent of women and 75 percent of men did household activities on an average day, and on those days women averaged 2.8 hours and men 2.1 hours.

For a simple example, suppose a back injury means you need four hours a week of cleaning help, and local services charge $25 an hour. That is $100 a week, or about $5,200 a year. If doctors expect the restriction to last two years, the projected loss is roughly $10,400. A permanent restriction may support a claim for replacement services over your remaining life expectancy, depending on the medical evidence and how long the services are expected to be needed. Future damages may also require a present-value calculation, which accounts for the fact that money received today can earn interest over time. States have different rules for these adjustments and how inflation is considered. An economist may help calculate the projected loss under the rules that apply to your case.

Experience with these calculations is one of the things to consider when choosing a personal injury lawyer, because household services are easy to undervalue or leave out.

Frequently Asked Questions About Household Services Damages

Can I Claim Household Services if Family Members Are Helping for Free?

It depends on which state's law applies to your claim. Some courts value the services themselves and have allowed recovery even when relatives provided the help for free. New York's highest court has rejected recovery for past household help that cost the injured person nothing, though it does allow future household services that are reasonably certain to be needed because of the injury. Keeping receipts for any paid help and documenting the help family provides protects the claim under either approach.

How Long Can Replacement-Service Costs Be Included?

You can include replacement-service costs for as long as the injury is expected to keep you from doing the work. A temporary restriction supports a claim for the recovery period your doctors describe. A permanent restriction can support a claim projected over your remaining life expectancy. Future amounts must be reasonably certain to result from the injury, which is why medical opinions about how long the limits will last carry so much weight in these claims.

Can My Spouse Recover for the Loss of My Help Around the House?

Possibly. In many states, a spouse can bring a loss of consortium claim, which can include household services such as housework and cooking, as well as companionship. Each state sets its own rules for who may bring this claim and how it relates to the injured person's own damages, so ask how your state handles both claims before a demand goes out.

How Long Do I Have to File a Claim for These Losses?

When lost household services are included as damages in a personal injury lawsuit, they follow the filing deadline for that lawsuit. In some states, a spouse may also have a separate claim for lost household services, which can have its own filing requirements. Deadlines vary by state and by the type of case. For example, Tennessee has a one-year deadline for many personal injury lawsuits, while Maine has a six-year general deadline, but exceptions and different rules can apply. The date the deadline begins, tolling rules for minors, and special requirements for claims against government entities can also affect how much time you have. If the applicable deadline expires and no exception applies, your claim may be barred. Confirm the filing requirements for your case as early as possible.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, Is Just One Phone Call Away

An injury that takes away your ability to run your household creates costs that do not show up on a medical bill. Those losses deserve the same documentation as any other part of your claim.

At Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, our team documents how an injury changes daily life at home, gathers the medical support behind each restriction, and presents the value of lost household work to insurers and juries.

Contact us today for a free legal consultation.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult an attorney for advice regarding your specific situation.

Still have questions?

Speak to an attorney today

Call now and be done