If you've been injured in an accident in Massachusetts, whether on the job or due to someone else's negligence, the path to recovering fair compensation can be complex. Along this journey, you may be asked to attend an Independent Medical Examination, or IME. While the name suggests an objective assessment, it's important to understand that these examinations are requested and paid for by the insurance company. The doctor performing the IME is not your treating physician and is hired to provide a medical opinion on your condition. This opinion can significantly impact your claim.

Understanding when an IME can be required, what the process entails, and what your rights are is fundamental to protecting your claim. This article will provide a thorough overview of IMEs in Massachusetts for both workers' compensation and personal injury cases, helping you navigate this often-misunderstood step in the claims process.

The Role of an Independent Medical Examination (IME) in Massachusetts

An IME is a medical evaluation conducted by a physician who has not previously been involved in your care. The purpose of this examination is for the insurance company to obtain a medical opinion on various aspects of your injury and claim. This can include the cause and extent of your injuries, the appropriateness of your current treatment plan, and your ability to return to work.

It is important to recognize that the term "independent" can be misleading. The examining physician is selected and compensated by the insurance company, which may create a potential for bias. The report generated from this examination can be used by the insurer to justify denying or terminating your benefits. Therefore, approaching an IME with a clear understanding of its purpose and your rights is essential.

When Can an Insurer Request an IME?

In Massachusetts, an insurer can request an IME in several situations. For those with a MA workers' comp claim, an IME may be requested shortly after the injury is reported to verify that it is work-related. It can also be requested at various points during the claim, particularly if the insurer questions the necessity of ongoing treatment or believes you have reached what is known as "maximum medical improvement." This is the point at which your condition is not expected to improve further.

In the context of a personal injury claim, such as one arising from a car accident, an IME may be required if you are receiving Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits. The insurer may use an IME to determine if further medical treatment is reasonable and necessary.

IMEs and Your MA Workers' Comp Claim

For injured workers in Massachusetts, the workers' compensation system has specific rules governing IMEs. Understanding these regulations is key to ensuring your rights are protected throughout the process. A knowledgeable workers compensation lawyer in MA can be an invaluable asset in navigating these complexities.

The Legal Framework for IMEs in Massachusetts Workers' Compensation

Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 152, Section 45, grants an insurer the right to require an injured employee to attend a medical examination "from time to time." This means that an insurer can request more than one IME over the course of your claim. However, these requests must be reasonable.

If you refuse to attend a scheduled IME without a valid reason, the insurer has the right to suspend your weekly benefits. This makes it incredibly important to attend all scheduled examinations or to have your attorney address any legitimate scheduling conflicts with the insurer.

Key Aspects of the IME Process in a MA Workers' Comp Claim:

  • Notice: The insurer must provide you with written notice of the scheduled IME, including the date, time, and location of the appointment, as well as the name of the examining physician.
  • Reasonable Location: The examination must be scheduled at a location that is reasonably accessible from your home.
  • Travel Reimbursement: The insurance company is required to reimburse you for your travel expenses to and from the IME. If you are unable to drive due to your injuries, they may also be responsible for arranging transportation.
  • Physician's Specialty: The examining doctor should be a specialist in the field of medicine relevant to your specific injuries.

The "Impartial" Medical Examination in Disputed Claims

If there is a dispute over your medical condition that proceeds to a hearing at the Department of Industrial Accidents (DIA), a different type of medical examination comes into play. Under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 152, Section 11A, an "impartial medical examiner" is appointed. This physician is selected from a roster maintained by the DIA and is not chosen by either you or the insurer.

The report from this impartial physician is considered "prima facie" evidence, meaning it is accepted as fact unless proven otherwise. This gives the impartial examiner's opinion significant weight in the outcome of your case. An experienced workers compensation lawyer in MA can help you prepare for this examination and can challenge the report if there are grounds to do so.

The IME in Massachusetts Personal Injury Cases

While most commonly associated with workers' compensation, IMEs also play a significant role in personal injury claims in Massachusetts. If you've been injured in a car accident, a slip and fall, or another incident caused by someone else's negligence, you may be required to attend an IME. An MA personal injury lawyer can provide guidance on how to handle this request.

IMEs and Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Benefits

In Massachusetts, all drivers are required to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage. This no-fault insurance provides up to $8,000 in benefits for medical expenses, lost wages, and replacement services, regardless of who was at fault for the accident.

If you are receiving PIP benefits, the insurance company may require you to attend an IME to verify the necessity of your ongoing medical treatment. The IME report can be used by the insurer to terminate your PIP benefits if the examining physician determines that further treatment is not medically necessary or that your injuries are not related to the accident.

IMEs in Third-Party Personal Injury Lawsuits

If your injuries are severe and your damages exceed the available PIP coverage, you may file a lawsuit against the at-fault party. In this situation, the defendant's insurance company may request that you undergo an IME. The purpose of this examination is for their chosen doctor to provide an opinion on the extent of your injuries and their impact on your life. This report will be used to counter the medical evidence presented by your own treating physicians and can influence settlement negotiations and a potential trial verdict.

What to Expect During a Personal Injury IME:

  • Review of Medical Records: The IME doctor will have access to your medical records and will likely ask you questions about your medical history, the accident, and your symptoms.
  • Physical Examination: The doctor will conduct a physical examination focused on your injuries.
  • No Doctor-Patient Relationship: It is important to remember that the IME doctor is not your treating physician. You should not ask for medical advice or treatment during the examination.
  • Be Honest and Consistent: It is essential to be truthful about your symptoms and limitations. Exaggerating your injuries can harm your credibility. At the same time, do not downplay your pain or difficulties.

Preparing for Your IME in Massachusetts

Being prepared for your IME can help ensure that the examination is a fair and accurate reflection of your condition.

Before the Examination

  • Review Your Medical History: Be familiar with your medical records, including the dates of treatment and the names of your providers.
  • Consult with Your Attorney: Your MA personal injury lawyer or workers compensation lawyer in MA can provide you with specific advice on what to expect and how to conduct yourself during the examination.
  • Make a List of Your Symptoms: It can be helpful to write down a list of your current symptoms and how they affect your daily activities. This can help you provide a comprehensive and accurate account to the IME doctor.

During the Examination

  • Arrive on Time: Punctuality demonstrates that you are taking the process seriously.
  • Be Polite and Respectful: Maintain a courteous demeanor throughout the examination, even if you feel the doctor is being dismissive or unfair.
  • Be Detailed in Your Responses: When asked about your injuries and symptoms, provide clear and detailed answers. Avoid simple "yes" or "no" responses.
  • Do Not Sign Any Forms Without Consulting Your Attorney: The IME doctor's office may ask you to sign forms. Do not sign anything without first having it reviewed by your legal counsel.

After the Examination

  • Make Notes: Immediately after the examination, write down everything you can remember about the appointment. This should include how long the examination lasted, what questions were asked, what tests were performed, and any comments the doctor made.
  • Inform Your Attorney: Contact your lawyer to let them know that the examination has been completed and to share your notes.
  • See Your Own Doctor: It can be beneficial to schedule an appointment with your own treating physician shortly after the IME. This creates a contemporaneous medical record from a doctor who is familiar with your condition.

What if You Disagree with the IME Report?

If the IME report contains inaccuracies or presents an unfair assessment of your condition, it is not the end of your claim. An experienced attorney can take several steps to challenge the findings. This can include deposing the IME doctor to question them under oath about their opinions and the basis for them. Your lawyer can also use the medical evidence from your treating physicians to counter the IME report.

In a MA workers' comp claim, if you disagree with the findings of an impartial medical examiner, your attorney can petition the judge to allow for the submission of additional medical evidence if the impartial report is deemed inadequate or the medical issues are particularly complex.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, is One Phone Call Away

Navigating the complexities of an Independent Medical Examination in Massachusetts can be stressful and intimidating, especially when you are focused on recovering from your injuries. The outcome of your IME can have a substantial impact on your ability to receive the compensation you deserve.

At Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, our team of experienced workers' compensation and personal injury lawyers understands the tactics that insurance companies use to minimize or deny claims. We are dedicated to protecting the rights of our clients and ensuring they are treated fairly throughout the legal process. If you have been asked to attend an IME or have questions about your personal injury or workers' compensation claim, contact us today for a free consultation. We are here to provide you with the knowledgeable and compassionate legal representation you need to achieve the best possible outcome.

Still have questions?

Call now and be done