When a personal injury case settles in Ohio, the injured party usually has two options for receiving compensation: a lump sum or a structured settlement. Each approach has advantages and limitations, and the choice can significantly impact financial stability, tax implications, and long-term well-being. Making an informed decision requires understanding how these payout types function within the framework of Ohio personal injury law.

Lump Sum Settlements in Ohio: Immediate Access to Funds

What Is a Lump Sum Settlement?

A lump sum settlement is a one-time payment that covers the entirety of the compensation agreed upon between the injured party and the liable party or insurer. Once paid, the case is considered closed, and the injured party assumes full control over the funds.

Benefits of a Lump Sum Payout

  • Immediate financial relief: Ideal for covering urgent expenses such as medical bills, lost wages, or debt.
  • Flexible use of funds: The recipient can invest, save, or spend the money as they choose without restrictions.
  • One-and-done resolution: There’s no need to manage or track future payments.

Potential Drawbacks

  • Risk of poor financial management: Without a long-term financial plan, recipients may spend the money too quickly.
  • No ongoing support: Once the lump sum is used, there are no additional payments—even if future medical needs arise.
  • Tax implications for certain damages: While compensation for physical injury is generally non-taxable, interest or punitive damages could trigger tax liability.

When Is a Lump Sum Settlement Recommended?

Lump sums may be ideal for individuals who:

  • Need to pay off significant debts or medical expenses immediately.
  • Prefer managing their own finances or have access to trusted financial advisors.
  • Are capable of budgeting and investing for the long term.

Structured Settlements in Ohio: Long-Term Financial Support

How Structured Settlements Work

A structured settlement provides compensation through periodic payments over a set timeline—monthly, annually, or in customized intervals. The terms are tailored to the injured party’s projected future needs and may continue for years or even a lifetime.

Advantages of Structured Settlements

  • Predictable income stream: Beneficial for those who cannot return to work or need long-term medical care.
  • Tax efficiency: Payments for physical injury are typically exempt from federal and Ohio state taxes.
  • Custom-tailored design: Payment schedules can include lump-sum start-up funds, followed by regular installments.
  • Protects against overspending: The payment structure naturally prevents rapid depletion of settlement funds.

Limitations of Structured Settlements

  • Limited flexibility: Once established, the payment schedule is usually fixed and cannot be adjusted without significant legal and financial hurdles.
  • Inflation concerns: Over time, fixed payments may lose purchasing power unless they’re indexed for inflation.
  • Not ideal for major upfront expenses: It may not provide enough liquidity for urgent or large one-time costs unless the structure includes an initial lump payment.

Who Benefits Most from Structured Settlements?

Structured payouts are especially beneficial for:

  • Minors or individuals with limited financial experience.
  • People with permanent disabilities requiring lifelong medical care.
  • Claimants interested in long-term financial stability and tax-deferred growth.

Ohio Laws and Legal Framework for Settlements

Ohio courts generally permit both lump sum and structured settlements in personal injury cases. However, certain cases—especially those involving minors or incapacitated individuals—may require court approval to ensure the settlement is in the best interest of the claimant.

In wrongful death or catastrophic injury cases, structured settlements are often encouraged due to the long-term nature of the damages. Ohio Revised Code § 2323.51 allows courts to consider the reasonableness of the settlement and its long-term sufficiency in protecting the injured party.

Attorneys representing injured parties in Ohio typically collaborate with structured settlement consultants, financial planners, and insurance companies to ensure the plan meets legal standards and the client’s financial needs.

Real-Life Applications in Ohio Courts

To better understand how these settlements play out in practice, consider these examples:

  • Case Example 1: Franklin County Slip and Fall
  • A 48-year-old woman sustained a serious back injury after slipping on an icy sidewalk outside a retail store. The insurer offered a $500,000 lump sum. After consulting with a financial advisor, she accepted it, using part for spinal surgery and investing the rest for retirement. Her ability to manage funds made the lump sum a wise choice.
  • Case Example 2: Cuyahoga County Auto Accident
  • A 12-year-old boy suffered a traumatic brain injury in a car crash. The court approved a structured settlement that provided an upfront payment for initial care, followed by annual payments through adulthood. This safeguarded his financial future and ensured continuous access to medical support.

These scenarios show how personal circumstances—age, injury type, future needs—strongly influence the right payout option.

Comparing Lump Sum and Structured Settlements: Key Factors

When evaluating which settlement option is best, claimants and their attorneys should consider:

1. Financial Needs

  • Are there pressing debts or expenses requiring immediate cash?
  • Is the claimant comfortable managing a large sum independently?

2. Medical Forecast

3. Age and Life Stage

4. Tax Implications

  • While personal injury compensation is largely tax-free, structured settlements offer continued tax shielding over time.

5. Risk Tolerance

  • Lump sums require a proactive approach to avoid overspending.
  • Structured payouts act as a safeguard against rapid depletion of funds.

Conclusion

Choosing between a lump sum and a structured settlement in an Ohio personal injury case isn’t a one-size-fits-all decision. Each has unique advantages and risks tied to the injured person’s age, health, financial acumen, and long-term needs. While lump sum settlements offer flexibility and immediate access to funds, structured settlements provide stability, tax benefits, and protection against future financial uncertainty. Working with experienced legal and financial professionals can help ensure the chosen path supports both recovery and future security.

Need Legal Help? Call Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating Ohio personal injury claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced personal injury lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.

Contact us now for a free legal review.

Still have questions?

Call now and be done