You trip over a pallet you left in the aisle at work and hurt your knee. When it’s time to report the injury, you wonder whether leaving the pallet there could cost you workers’ comp.
Pennsylvania workers’ compensation is a no-fault system. You generally don’t have to prove your employer did anything wrong, and an ordinary mistake on your part won’t disqualify you. If your claim is disputed, you’ll need to show how the injury is connected to your job. If you’re asking for wage-loss benefits, you’ll also need to show how the injury affected what you could earn.
Key Takeaways About Proving Fault in a Pennsylvania Workers’ Comp Claim
- You generally don’t have to prove anyone was careless to qualify for Pennsylvania workers’ comp.
- If your claim is disputed, you’ll need evidence connecting your injury to your work. For wage-loss benefits, you’ll also need to show that the injury reduced your ability to earn your usual wages.
- Ordinary mistakes generally won’t cost you benefits. Pennsylvania law does allow employers to raise certain defenses, including intoxication that caused the injury.
- Report the injury promptly, even if it seems minor. The deadline to notify your employer is separate from the deadline to file a claim petition.
What Do You Have to Prove in a Pennsylvania Workers’ Comp Claim?
If your employer or its insurer disputes your claim, you’ll need to show that you were injured in the course of your employment and that the injury was related to your work. What you were doing matters. A delivery driver injured while making a delivery may qualify even though the crash happened away from the employer’s property.
An injury can also develop over time. If lifting boxes every day makes an existing back condition worse, for example, that worsening may qualify for workers’ comp. When the connection between your work and the injury isn’t obvious, you generally need medical testimony explaining how the job caused or aggravated the condition.
The evidence you’ll need depends on what’s in dispute and which benefits you’re seeking:
- Incident details. Keep a copy of your injury report and write down what you were doing, where you were and when you first noticed symptoms.
- Medical records. Records of your diagnosis and treatment help document the injury. Tell your medical provider what happened or which job duties seem to make your symptoms worse.
- Witnesses. Write down the names of coworkers who saw the incident or can describe the work you were doing.
- Work restrictions and pay records. If you’re seeking wage-loss benefits, these records can help show how the injury kept you from working your usual hours or earning your usual pay.
Can a Mistake or a Safety Rule Violation Cost You Benefits?
An ordinary mistake, such as leaving a pallet in the aisle or lifting a box awkwardly, generally won’t disqualify you. Breaking a safety rule while doing your job also generally won’t cost you benefits on its own.
In rare cases, a claim can be denied if you were injured doing something outside your job duties that your employer had specifically told you not to do. To use that defense, the employer must show that the prohibited activity was outside your job duties, that you knew about the order and that breaking it caused your injury.
Pennsylvania law also bars benefits if you intentionally injure yourself or if breaking the law, including illegally using drugs, causes your injury. Intoxication can bar benefits if the injury would not have happened without it. The employer has to prove that the exclusion applies.
How Soon Should You Report a Work Injury in Pennsylvania?
Tell your employer or supervisor as soon as you can, even if you finish your shift or the injury seems minor. Explain what happened, when and where it happened, and what part of your body was injured. Reporting it in writing gives you a record to keep.
If your employer doesn’t already know about your work injury, report it within 21 days. If you report it after 21 days, you generally can’t receive benefits for the period before you gave notice. If you wait more than 120 days, you can lose your right to benefits altogether. If you couldn’t reasonably have known right away that you were injured or that the injury might be work-related, both deadlines start when you knew or reasonably should have known about the injury and its possible link to work.
When Does Fault Matter in a Separate Claim?
Workers’ compensation is generally your only remedy against your employer for a covered work injury. If another driver caused the injury, you may also have a third-party claim.
Say another driver runs a red light and hits you while you’re making a delivery. You can seek workers’ comp for the work injury without proving who caused the crash. In a separate negligence claim against the other driver, you would need to show that their careless driving caused your injuries. If defective equipment injured you, you may have a strict product liability claim against the manufacturer. You’d need to show that the defect existed when the equipment left the manufacturer’s control and that it caused your injury.
If you recover money from a third party, your employer or its workers’ comp insurer may have a right to reimbursement for benefits it paid.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can workers’ comp cover my medical bills if I never missed work?
Pennsylvania workers’ comp can pay for reasonable medical treatment related to a qualifying work injury even if you never miss a shift. Wage-loss benefits have separate requirements. If your injury forces you to work fewer hours or take a lower-paying assignment, your medical restrictions and pay records can help show the effect on your earnings.
What if nobody saw my work injury happen?
You can still have a claim. A prompt report, medical records and a clear account of what you were doing when you were hurt can all help. A coworker who didn’t see the injury happen may still be able to describe your duties or what they noticed afterward.
What happens if my Pennsylvania workers’ comp claim is denied?
Read the denial notice to see why the employer or insurer is disputing the claim. Keep the notice, your injury report and your medical records. You can challenge an initial denial by filing a claim petition, which generally must be filed within three years of the injury. A workers’ compensation judge will consider the evidence and decide whether you’re entitled to benefits.
Get Legal Help with Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law
If your employer is blaming you for an accident or the insurer doubts that your injury is work-related, our Pennsylvania workers’ compensation attorneys can review the denial, explain what evidence may help and walk you through your options.
Our team is available 24/7 for a free consultation. Contact us today.