Loss of Earning Capacity After Personal Injury: How Much Can I Claim in MA?

A serious accident does more than leave you with physical pain and a mountain of medical bills. It can fundamentally alter the course of your life, especially your ability to work and provide for your family. While you may receive compensation for the wages you lost during your immediate recovery, what about the money you will no longer be able to earn years—or even decades—from now? This significant, often overlooked, category of damages is known as loss of earning capacity.

Victims of negligence in Massachusetts have the right to seek compensation for this future financial harm. However, calculating and proving this loss is one of the most complex aspects of a personal injury claim. It’s not about the job you had; it’s about the career potential that was taken from you.

This article explains what loss of earning capacity means in the context of a Massachusetts personal injury claim, how it is calculated, and what it takes to build a case that secures the full and fair compensation you deserve for your diminished future earnings.

The Real Impact of a Massachusetts Personal Injury on Your Future Earnings

After an accident, the most immediate financial worry is often the stack of paystubs you’re no longer collecting. This is a straightforward loss. But what happens when a construction worker can no longer lift heavy materials, a surgeon suffers a nerve injury in her hand, or a student sustains a brain injury that prevents him from completing his degree? The financial damage extends far beyond the initial recovery period.

More Than Just Missed Paychecks: Lost Wages vs. Loss of Earning Capacity

It is important to understand the distinction between these two types of economic damages, as they cover different periods of financial loss.

Lost Wages: This is a backward-looking calculation. It represents the specific, verifiable income you lost from the time of your injury until you were able to return to work or your case was resolved. It includes your salary, hourly pay, bonuses, commissions, and overtime you would have earned. Proving lost wages typically involves submitting pay stubs, employment records, and a doctor's note confirming your inability to work.
Loss of Earning Capacity: This is a forward-looking projection. It compensates you for the reduction in your ability to earn money in the future. It is not based on a specific job but on your overall potential. You can have a claim for loss of earning capacity even if you were unemployed at the time of the accident or if you are able to return to your old job in a limited capacity. It addresses the difference between what you would have earned over your lifetime and what you can now realistically earn with your new limitations.

For example, imagine a 30-year-old electrician who earns $75,000 per year suffers a permanent back injury in a car accident. He can no longer handle the physical demands of the job and takes a desk job paying $45,000 per year.

His lost wages would be the income he missed during his months of recovery.
His loss of earning capacity would be the $30,000 annual difference, projected over the remaining 35 years of his working life, adjusted for inflation, potential promotions, and other factors. As you can see, this figure can be substantial.

How is Loss of Earning Capacity Calculated in Massachusetts?

There is no simple calculator or formula to determine the value of a loss of earning capacity claim. Unlike lost wages, which are based on hard numbers, this calculation is a sophisticated analysis of your life’s trajectory before the injury versus your new, limited path forward.

Insurance companies will often fight these claims vigorously because they represent a significant financial liability. A successful claim requires a detailed and evidence-based assessment of numerous individual factors.

Key Factors That Determine Your Claim Value

When building a case for lost future earnings, your personal injury lawyer will work with experts to analyze and present a comprehensive picture of your life. The key factors considered include

Your Age and Health: A younger individual has more working years ahead of them, which typically results in a larger claim for lost future earnings compared to someone nearing retirement. Your overall health before the accident is also considered.
Your Education, Skills, and Training: Your level of education, certifications, specialized skills, and on-the-job training all contribute to your pre-injury earning potential.
Your Work History and Career Trajectory: A consistent history of employment, promotions, and increasing income demonstrates a clear upward career path that has now been disrupted.
The Nature and Severity of Your Injuries: This is the foundation of the claim. Medical evidence must clearly define the permanent nature of your injuries and establish specific physical or cognitive limitations.
Your Life Expectancy and Work-Life Expectancy: Statistical data is used to project how long you were expected to live and work, forming the timeline over which your losses are calculated.
Economic Conditions: Factors like inflation rates and the general economic outlook for your profession are considered to ensure the final figure accurately reflects future economic realities.

Building a Strong Case for Loss of Future Earnings in a Personal Injury Claim

Because a claim for loss of future earnings is speculative by nature, Massachusetts courts require that it be proven with reasonable certainty. This means you cannot simply state that you are unable to earn what you once did. You must build a powerful, evidence-based argument, which almost always requires the help of a skilled legal team and qualified expert witnesses.

The Critical Role of Medical Evidence

The foundation of your claim is your medical record. Your doctors and medical specialists must provide detailed documentation that goes beyond diagnosing your injury. Their reports must clearly outline your permanent functional limitations.

This could include restrictions on:

Lifting, carrying, pushing, or pulling weight
Sitting, standing, or walking for extended periods
Fine motor skills and dexterity
Cognitive functions like memory, concentration, and problem-solving

This medical evidence establishes the why behind your diminished earning capacity. It provides the concrete, objective proof that your ability to perform certain types of work has been permanently compromised.

Why Expert Testimony is Essential for Proving Your Loss

While medical records are the foundation, expert witnesses are the architects who build the structure of your claim. In Massachusetts, successfully proving loss of earning capacity is nearly impossible without the testimony of two key types of professionals: vocational experts and forensic economists.

The Vocational Expert: Defining Your Pre- and Post-Injury Potential

A vocational expert is a specialist who evaluates a person's skills, education, and work history to determine their place in the labor market. For your claim, they will conduct a two-part analysis:

Pre-Injury Earning Capacity: The expert will assess your full potential before the accident. This might be higher than the salary of the job you held at the time. They will identify the full range of jobs you were qualified for and your likely career progression.
Post-Injury Earning Capacity: After reviewing your medical records and limitations, the expert will determine what types of work, if any, you can still perform. They will research the availability of such jobs in your geographic area and the typical wages they command.

The difference between these two assessments establishes the extent of your vocational disability.

The Forensic Economist: Translating Potential into a Dollar Figure

Once the vocational expert has defined your loss in terms of work and wages, a forensic accountant takes that data and translates it into a specific dollar amount. This expert will:

Calculate the total lifetime difference between your pre-injury and post-injury earning capacities.
Factor in predictable variables like inflation, cost-of-living increases, and the value of lost benefits (like 401(k) contributions and health insurance).
Account for likely promotions and career advancement you would have achieved.
Finally, they will discount the total future loss to its present-day value. This is the lump sum of money you would need to be awarded today to equal the total amount you would have lost over the course of your career.

Real-World Scenarios: What Does Loss of Earning Capacity Look Like?

The Injured Contractor: A 45-year-old self-employed carpenter suffers a severe shoulder injury in a fall caused by a defective scaffold. Multiple surgeries fail to restore his full range of motion. A vocational expert determines he can no longer perform the skilled carpentry work that was his livelihood. The expert identifies that his only transferable skills are for supervisory roles, which are less available and pay significantly less. An economist then calculates this annual income deficit over his remaining 20 working years.
The Aspiring Professional: A 21-year-old college student is in a T-bone collision and sustains a moderate traumatic brain injury (TBI). While she eventually recovers enough to live independently, she suffers from permanent concentration and memory issues. Her doctors and a neuropsychologist conclude she can no longer handle the rigorous demands of the accounting degree she was pursuing. A vocational expert testifies that her future is now limited to low-skill administrative work, and an economist calculates the vast difference in lifetime earnings between an accountant and an administrative assistant.

Why You Need an Experienced Massachusetts Personal Injury Attorney

Calculating and proving a claim for loss of earning capacity is a battle. Insurance companies have teams of lawyers and their own experts dedicated to minimizing or denying these claims. They may argue that you are not as injured as you claim or that you could find other work that pays just as well.

Attempting to navigate this process alone is a significant risk. An experienced personal injury attorney in MA is your most important advocate. After hiring an attorney, they will be able to level the playing field by:

Thoroughly Investigating Your Case: We gather all the necessary evidence, from medical records to employment files.
Engaging World-Class Experts: We have an established network of highly respected vocational and economic experts whose testimony is credible and persuasive in court. We also cover the upfront costs of hiring these professionals.
Building a Compelling Narrative: We weave the evidence and expert opinions into a clear and powerful story that demonstrates the true extent of your losses to an insurance adjuster, judge, or jury.
Aggressively Negotiating on Your Behalf: We know the tactics insurers use to undervalue these claims, and we will not let them pressure you into accepting less than you deserve.

Your future financial security is on the line. Don’t leave it to chance.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, is One Phone Call Away

If you or a loved one has suffered a serious injury in Massachusetts that has impacted your ability to work, you may be entitled to significant compensation for your loss of earning capacity. The legal team at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, is dedicated to helping clients secure their future. We have a long track record of success in handling complex personal injury claims and are ready to fight for you.

Consultation

Contact Us