When your child is diagnosed with cerebral palsy after a difficult delivery, it’s natural to wonder whether something happened during birth that could have been prevented. Cerebral palsy can result from medical malpractice in New Jersey when substandard care causes or contributes to an injury to the developing brain. A cerebral palsy diagnosis alone doesn’t tell you when the injury happened or whether a doctor, nurse, or hospital could have prevented it.

A review of your child’s care looks at what the medical team knew at the time, how they responded, and whether appropriate care could have prevented the injury or made it less severe. Prenatal records, labor and delivery records, and newborn evaluations can help answer those questions.

Key Takeaways About Cerebral Palsy and Medical Malpractice in New Jersey

  • Cerebral palsy can result from negligent care, but the diagnosis alone doesn’t establish malpractice.
  • Medical experts generally evaluate whether the care fell below accepted standards and whether that contributed to the child’s injury.
  • Fetal heart rate records, newborn evaluations, and brain imaging can help experts determine when an injury may have occurred.
  • In New Jersey, a child’s medical malpractice lawsuit for an injury sustained at birth generally must be filed before the child’s 13th birthday.
  • Compensation depends on the harm linked to the malpractice and the child’s individual needs, including care they may need in the future.

When Can Cerebral Palsy Support a Medical Malpractice Claim?

A claim may be possible if the medical team missed a warning sign, delayed a delivery that was medically necessary, or failed to recognize or treat severe newborn jaundice in time. In each case, the question is what the team should have done and how that care could have changed the outcome.

Cerebral palsy can result from abnormal brain development or damage to the developing brain before, during, or after birth. In many cases, the specific cause is unknown. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that a lack of oxygen during birth accounts for only a small share of cases.

Some complications, such as the placenta separating too early, can arise even when the medical team has provided appropriate care. A review may focus on how quickly the team recognized the emergency and what they did once they knew the baby was at risk.

What Standard of Care Applies During Labor and Delivery?

The standard of care is the level of care a provider should give under the circumstances. In New Jersey, expert testimony generally explains what accepted medical practice called for based on the information available to the provider at the time.

During labor, experts may look at how the team monitored the baby’s heart rate, managed medications, and communicated changes. If the baby’s heart rate repeatedly showed concerning changes, for example, an expert may evaluate whether the team should have reassessed the baby sooner, taken steps to address the problem, or delivered the baby earlier.

Hospital policies and professional guidelines can help explain the expected response. Experts also consider the circumstances of the delivery and what the medical records show about the care at the time.

How Do You Prove That a Medical Error Caused the Injury?

A missed warning sign is one part of the investigation. Medical experts also need to explain how the missed warning or delayed response contributed to the harm the child suffered.

If an injury may be related to a lack of oxygen, experts may review the baby’s heart rate during labor, blood tests from the umbilical cord, the newborn exam, and brain imaging together. A low Apgar score describes how the baby was doing shortly after birth. On its own, it can’t show that a lack of oxygen during labor caused cerebral palsy. Brain imaging may help experts assess when and how an injury occurred.

An existing medical condition may already put a child at risk of brain injury. In some cases, New Jersey law allows a family to prove causation by showing that negligent care increased that risk and that the increased risk played a substantial part in the harm the child suffered.

Which Medical Records and Experts Are Important?

A discharge summary rarely gives the full picture in a birth injury claim. Reviewing the mother’s prenatal and delivery records alongside the child’s newborn, neurological, and developmental records helps show what happened at each stage.

A review typically involves three steps.

  1. Gather the complete records, including fetal heart rate tracings, medication logs, delivery or surgical reports, and any available cord blood or placental test results.
  2. Put the events in order, including when warning signs appeared, who was notified, and when the medical team acted.
  3. Have qualified specialists assess the care and explain whether a different response could have prevented or reduced the harm.

The specialists involved depend on what happened. An obstetrician may review decisions made during labor and delivery. A neonatologist may review the care the baby received after birth. A pediatric neurologist or neuroradiologist may help explain what the child’s exams and imaging show.

In most New Jersey medical malpractice cases, the person bringing the claim must give each defendant an affidavit of merit within 60 days after that defendant files an answer to the lawsuit. In the affidavit, a qualified expert states that the care likely fell below accepted professional standards. A court may grant one extension of up to 60 days for good cause.

Compensation for a Child’s Long-Term Needs

Cerebral palsy affects each child differently. One child may need help with mobility and daily care, while another may need speech therapy or a device to help them communicate. Compensation should reflect the child’s individual needs and the harm caused by the malpractice.

A life care plan can help estimate the cost of therapies, specialist visits, equipment, personal assistance, and changes to make the home accessible. It can also account for how often a child will need services and when equipment may need replacing. In New Jersey, a claim for future medical care needs evidence that the child will likely need the care and that the estimated costs are reasonable.

Depending on the evidence, compensation may also account for pain and suffering, disability, loss of enjoyment of life, and a reduced ability to earn income as an adult.

An early settlement offer can be hard to evaluate while your child’s needs are still becoming clear. It helps to understand what the offer accounts for, especially if your child may need more assistance, therapy, or equipment as they grow.

Frequently Asked Questions About Cerebral Palsy and Medical Malpractice in New Jersey

Can a birth injury claim be filed if symptoms appear later?

A claim may still be possible if your child’s movement difficulties or missed milestones became apparent months or years after birth. The medical evidence still needs to connect the condition to negligent care, and you must still be within the time allowed to file. A later diagnosis by itself doesn’t start a new filing period. Developmental evaluations can help document when symptoms appeared and how they changed over time.

How Long Do You Have to File a Birth Injury Lawsuit in New Jersey?

If your child was injured at birth because of medical malpractice in New Jersey, a lawsuit on your child’s behalf generally must be filed before their 13th birthday. This is a special rule for injuries sustained at birth under N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2. A different deadline may apply if the injury occurred later, such as during newborn care.

The deadline is for filing the lawsuit. Gathering records and arranging for medical experts to review them can take time, so it’s worth looking into the applicable deadline when concerns first arise.

Get Legal Help with Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law

If you have questions about the care your child received before, during, or after birth, Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law can help you understand what a review would involve. We can discuss the medical records you have, what other information may help explain what happened, and whether you may have a New Jersey medical malpractice claim.

Our team is available 24/7. Contact us today. Your consultation is free.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult an attorney for advice regarding your specific situation.

Still have questions?

Speak to an attorney today

Call now and be done