If you needed more treatment after a medication mix-up or a missed warning sign, you may be wondering whether a nurse’s mistake made things worse.
You can file a medical malpractice claim for a nurse’s mistake in New Jersey if the nurse fell short of the care a reasonably careful nurse would have provided in the same situation and that mistake harmed you. For example, if a nurse gave you a medication despite an allergy listed in your chart and you had a serious reaction, you may have a claim. Depending on what happened, the nurse, the hospital, or another provider may be responsible.
Key Takeaways About Medical Malpractice Claims for a Nurse’s Mistake in New Jersey
- A nursing mistake can support a malpractice claim when substandard care causes harm.
- A hospital may be responsible for an employee’s nursing error or for its own failures, such as inadequate supervision.
- Medical records and expert opinions can help show what the nurse should have done and how the mistake affected your health.
- New Jersey generally requires an affidavit of merit for malpractice claims based on a registered nurse’s care. It’s usually due within 60 days after the defendant files an answer.
- Most adults have two years to file a lawsuit. Claims involving public hospitals or public employees may have a much earlier notice deadline.
- Compensation generally reflects the harm attributable to the nursing error, such as additional treatment, lost income, or worsening disability.
When Does a Nurse’s Mistake Become Medical Malpractice in New Jersey?
An unexpected complication can happen even when a nurse provides appropriate care. What matters is what a reasonably careful nurse would have done in the same circumstances. That depends on the patient’s condition, the information available at the time, the provider’s orders, and the nurse’s role.
Following a physician’s order is one part of providing appropriate care. Depending on the circumstances, a nurse may also need to clarify an unclear order, report a serious change in the patient’s condition, or seek help from another clinician if the initial response is inadequate.
What Types of Nursing Errors Can Lead to a Malpractice Claim?
Medication errors can include giving the wrong drug or dose, giving medication to the wrong patient, or administering it the wrong way. To support a claim, there must also be evidence that the error caused harm, such as an injury that required additional treatment.
Failures to monitor or communicate can be harder to spot. A nurse might record falling oxygen levels without alerting the appropriate clinician, miss signs of internal bleeding, or fail to pass along a serious change in the patient’s condition at shift change. What happened next matters. Timely action may have prevented a complication or made it less severe.
A hospital fall or pressure injury calls for a closer look at the care the patient received. Risk assessments, ordered precautions, and repositioning records can help show what staff were expected to do and whether a missed step contributed to the injury.
How Can Medical Records Help Prove a Nursing Malpractice Claim?
Medication administration records, vital signs, nursing notes, lab results, and communications with other clinicians can help show when a warning sign appeared and how staff responded. Electronic medical records may also help distinguish when care took place from when someone entered it in the chart.
A missing note can raise questions about whether care was provided. A checked box may also need a closer look if it conflicts with other chart entries, witness accounts, or the patient’s condition at the time.
The medical timeline can help answer three questions:
- What information should have prompted the nurse to act, and when was it available?
- What should the nurse have done in response?
- How might that response have prevented or reduced the harm?
When a patient already has a medical condition, it can be hard to tell how much a delay or missed warning sign changed the outcome. In some New Jersey malpractice cases, the patient can show that the nursing error increased the risk of harm from the existing condition and that the increased risk played a substantial part in the injury. For example, if a nurse failed to report signs of a worsening infection, medical experts can assess whether the delay increased the risk of serious complications and whether that increased risk played a substantial part in the harm the patient suffered.
Can a New Jersey Hospital Be Responsible for a Nurse’s Error?
A hospital may be legally responsible for an employed nurse’s negligence when the nurse was acting within the scope of their job. If a staffing agency supplied the nurse, the staffing agreement and who actually directed the nurse’s work can help determine which entities may be responsible.
A hospital may also be liable for its own failures, such as inadequate supervision or unsafe staffing practices. A busy unit or a low staffing level can be part of the evidence. A claim still needs to connect the hospital’s failure to the harm the patient suffered.
Other clinicians may share responsibility if their decisions also contributed to the injury. For example, a nurse may have alerted a provider about a serious change in the patient’s condition, and the provider’s response may need to be reviewed as well.
Expert Evidence and New Jersey’s Affidavit of Merit Requirement
Most nursing malpractice claims require expert testimony to explain what proper nursing care would have looked like in the circumstances. A qualified nursing expert can review what the nurse knew, what the nurse should have done, and how the care fell short. Depending on the injury, a physician or another qualified expert may also be needed to explain how the mistake affected the patient’s health.
New Jersey generally requires an affidavit of merit for a malpractice claim based on a registered nurse’s care. This can apply whether you sue the nurse, the hospital, or both. The affidavit is a sworn statement from a qualified, licensed professional who concludes that there is a reasonable probability the care fell below accepted standards. When required, the affidavit is generally due within 60 days after the defendant files an answer to the lawsuit. A court can grant one extension of up to 60 more days for good cause. Missing the deadline can lead to dismissal.
A malpractice claim based solely on a licensed practical nurse’s care generally does not require an affidavit of merit. A separate claim about the hospital’s own conduct, such as negligent supervision, may still require one. You may also need expert testimony to prove what went wrong and how it harmed you.
A narrow common-knowledge exception may apply when jurors can recognize the error without an expert explaining what proper care required. In Cowley v. Virtua Health System, hospital records indicated that a patient removed her feeding tube and refused to have it replaced. The New Jersey Supreme Court held that an affidavit of merit was required because jurors needed expert guidance to understand what the nurses should have done after the patient refused treatment.
What Compensation Can You Recover in a Nursing Malpractice Claim?
Recoverable losses may include additional medical treatment, rehabilitation, lost earnings, reduced ability to earn a living, and future care needs. Compensation may also account for pain, disability, and loss of enjoyment of life, especially when the injury makes everyday activities harder.
If you were already seriously ill, medical experts can help explain how your recovery likely would have gone with appropriate care. That comparison can show whether the error led to an avoidable complication, a longer hospital stay, or a greater need for help after discharge.
The type of nursing error alone tells you little about what a claim may be worth. Two patients who receive the same wrong dose can have very different outcomes. The harm each patient suffered and the evidence linking it to the error help determine what compensation may be available.
How Long Do You Have to File a Nursing Malpractice Lawsuit in New Jersey?
Most adults have two years to file a nursing malpractice lawsuit in New Jersey under N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2. The discovery rule may delay the start of that period until you knew or reasonably should have known that you were injured and that negligent care may have caused the injury.
If the New Jersey Tort Claims Act applies to your claim against a public hospital or public employee, you generally have 90 days from the date your claim legally begins to submit a formal notice of claim. You generally must wait six months after the public entity receives that notice before filing suit. The two-year deadline to file the lawsuit still applies. Claims involving children can also follow different deadlines. A medical malpractice lawsuit for an injury sustained at birth generally must be filed before the child’s 13th birthday. A hospital grievance, insurance discussion, or licensing complaint generally does not pause the lawsuit deadline.
Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away
If you needed more treatment or spent longer in the hospital after a suspected nursing error, Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law can review what happened and help you understand your options. Our team is available 24/7, and we offer free consultations.