Skip to main content

Consultation

Fill out the form below to reach out to our Support team.
Injuries Category
We aim to respond as quickly as possible, but allow 1 to 2 working days for a reply.
Brandon J. Broderick
(877) 448-7350
(877) 448-7350
  • Home
  • Locations
    • Connecticut
      • Bridgeport Office

        2320 Main St. Suite 2B

        Bridgeport, CT 06606

      • Danbury Office

        51 Sugar Hollow Rd #202a

        Danbury, CT 06810

      • Groton Office

        554 Long Hill Rd #6

        Groton, CT 06340

      • Hartford Office

        609 Farmington Ave #LL1

        Hartford, CT 06105

      • Meriden Office

        325 Chamberlain Hwy

        Meriden, CT 06451

      • Milford Office

        63 Cherry Street, Second Floor

        Milford, CT 06460

      • New Britain Office

        450 S Main St, Suite 201

        New Britain, CT 06051

      • New Haven Office

        240 Bradley St

        New Haven, CT 06510

      • Norwalk Office

        161 East Ave #208

        Norwalk, CT 06851

      • Norwich Office

        315 W Main St. Suite 5

        Norwich, CT 06360

      • Stamford Office

        500 Newfield Ave #12c

        Stamford, CT 06905

      • Torrington Office

        299 Industrial Ln #4

        Torrington, CT 06790

      • Waterbury Office

        1068 W Main St, Suite 6

        Waterbury, CT 06708

    • Florida
      • Jacksonville Office

        6316 San Juan Ave #15

        Jacksonville, FL 32210

      • Miami Office

        111 SW 3rd St

        Miami, FL 33130

      • Pinellas Park Office

        7381 114th Ave #403c

        Pinellas Park, FL 33782

    • Kentucky
      • Louisville Office

        501 East Broadway Suite 380

        Louisville, KY 40202

    • Massachusetts
      • Amherst Office

        17 Pray St

        Amherst, MA 01002

      • Boston Office

        15 Court Square #560

        Boston, MA 02108

      • Brockton Office

        33 Dover Street

        Brockton, MA 02301

      • Cambridge Office

        552 Massachusetts Ave #213

        Cambridge, MA 02139

      • Fall River Office

        36 Fifth St. Suite 14

        Fall River, MA 02720

      • Fitchburg Office

        47 Ashby State Rd

        Fitchburg, MA 01420

      • Lawrence Office

        599 Canal St

        Lawrence, MA 01840

      • Lowell Office

        16 Stedman St #5,

        Lowell, MA 01851

      • Lynn Office

        271 Western Ave #211c

        Lynn, MA 01904

      • New Bedford Office

        34 Welby Rd #207

        New Bedford, MA 02745

      • Quincy Office

        299 Newport Ave

        Quincy, MA 02170

      • Somerville Office

        402A Highland Avenue, Suite K

        Somerville, MA 02114

      • Springfield Office

        235 Chestnut St., Unit 9

        Springfield, MA 01103

      • Worcester Office

        67 Millbrook St., Suite 421

        Worcester, MA 01606

    • New Jersey
      • Asbury Park Office

        603 Mattison Ave. Suite 322

        Asbury Park, NJ 07712

      • Atlantic City Office

        1125 Atlantic Ave #511

        Atlantic City, NJ 08401

      • Bayonne Office

        654 Avenue C #204

        Bayonne, NJ 07002

      • Bordentown Office

        217 US-130

        Bordentown, NJ 08505

      • Brick Office

        522 Brick Blvd #203-3

        Brick Township, NJ 08723

      • Camden Office

        808 Market St Third floor

        Camden, NJ 08102

      • Cherry Hill Office

        102 Browning Ln #5

        Cherry Hill, NJ 08003

      • Clifton Office

        85 Central Ave

        Clifton, NJ 07011

      • Edison Office

        505 Thornall St Suite 205

        Edison, NJ 08837

      • Elizabeth Office

        333 N Broad St #206

        Elizabeth, NJ 07208

      • Ewing Office

        850 Bear Tavern Rd Suite 106

        Ewing, NJ 08628

      • Freehold Office

        41 Center St #105

        Freehold, NJ 07728

      • Hackensack Office

        3 University Plaza Dr 6th Floor

        Hackensack, NJ 07601

      • Irvington Office

        40 Union Ave #402

        Irvington, NJ 07111

      • Jersey City Office

        840 Bergen Ave Second Floor

        Jersey City, NJ 07306

      • Lakewood Office

        216 River Ave

        Lakewood, NJ 08701

      • Millburn Office

        288 Main Street 2nd Floor

        Millburn, NJ 07041

      • Montclair Office

        248 Lorraine Ave

        Montclair, NJ 07043

      • Morristown Office

        914 Mt Kemble Ave #304

        Morristown, NJ 07960

      • Mount Laurel Office

        6000 Midlantic Dr

        Mount Laurel, NJ 08054

      • New Brunswick Office

        46 Bayard St Suite 216

        New Brunswick, NJ 08901

      • Newark Office

        41-43 Manufacturers Pl

        Newark, NJ 07105

      • Parsippany Office

        14 Walsh Dr Suite 200 Room 7

        Parsippany, NJ 07054

      • Paterson Office

        111 Washington St, Suite 111

        Paterson, NJ 07505

      • Princeton Office

        812 State Rd #203

        Princeton, NJ 08540

      • River Edge Office

        65 East Route 4

        River Edge, NJ 07661

      • Toms River Office

        25 Main Street Suite C

        Toms River, NJ 08753

      • Toms River Office

        64 Washington Street

        Toms River, NJ 08753

      • Trenton Office

        1331 Chambers Street

        Trenton, NJ 08610

      • Union City Office

        902 Central Ave

        Union City, NJ 07087

      • Vineland Office

        1667 E Landis Ave suite 14

        Vineland, NJ 08361

      • Woodbridge Office

        123 Green St #6

        Woodbridge, NJ 07095

    • New York
      • Albany Office

        21 Everett Rd Ext

        Albany, NY 12205

      • Binghamton Office

        34 Chenango St. Suite 410.

        Binghamton, NY 13904

      • Bronx Office

        2451 White Plains Rd #1

        Bronx, NY 10467

      • Bronx Office

        111 Bruckner Blvd, Suite 301

        Bronx, NY 10454

      • Brooklyn Office

        6400 18th Ave Second Floor

        Brooklyn, NY 11204

      • Buffalo Office

        300 Main St #8

        Buffalo, NY 14202

      • Cheektowaga Office

        2355 Union Rd #200b

        Cheektowaga, NY 14227

      • Elmira Office

        227 W Water St

        Elmira, NY 14901

      • Flushing Office

        90-25 Elmhurst Ave #C-1500

        Flushing, NY 11372

      • Hamburg Office

        5811 South Park Ave, LLS

        Hamburg, NY 14075

      • Hempstead Office

        60 Hempstead Ave #6002

        West Hempstead, NY 11552

      • Huntington Office

        215 East Main Street, Suite 203

        Huntington, NY 11743

      • Ithaca Office

        301 W State St #302

        Ithaca, NY 14850

      • Islip Office

        55 Carleton Ave # 1

        East Islip, NY 11730

      • Jamestown Office

        2-6 E 2nd St 2nd Floor

        Jamestown, NY 14701

      • Long Island City Office

        9-20 35th Ave #2E10

        Long Island City, NY 11106

      • Middletown Office

        720 Route 17K

        Middletown, NY 10940

      • Mount Vernon Office

        6 Gramatan Ave, Suite 604E

        Mount Vernon, NY 10550

      • New Rochelle Office

        398 North Ave. Suite 210

        New Rochelle, NY 10801

      • New York Office

        11 Broadway Suite 615

        New York, NY 10022

      • New York Office

        40 W 37th St #400b

        New York, NY 10018

      • Newburgh Office

        259 NY-17K #203

        Newburgh, NY 12550

      • Niagara Falls Office

        2908 Military Rd Suite B

        Niagara Falls, NY 14304

      • Peekskill Office

        1000 N Division St

        Peekskill, NY 10566

      • Plattsburgh Office

        65 Court St 1st Floor

        Plattsburgh, NY 12901

      • Port Chester Office

        420 Westchester Ave #2C

        Port Chester, NY 10573

      • Poughkeepsie Office

        695 Dutchess Turnpike #203-C

        Poughkeepsie, NY 12603

      • Queens Office

        110-20 Jamaica Avenue, Suite 2H

        Queens, NY 11418

      • Rochester Office

        1765 Mount Hope Avenue

        Rochester, NY 14620

      • Rochester Office

        127 Railroad St #255

        Rochester, NY 14609

      • Saratoga Springs Office

        200 West Ave #200

        Saratoga Springs, NY 12866

      • Schenectady Office

        26 Broadway Suite 206

        Schenectady, NY 12305

      • Smithtown Office

        186 W Main St

        Smithtown, NY 11787

      • Staten Island Office

        2071 Clove Rd Suite 202

        Staten Island, NY 10304

      • Syracuse Office

        112 Dewitt St #204

        Syracuse, NY 13203

      • Utica Office

        502 Court St. Suite 210

        Utica, NY 13502

      • Watertown Office

        724 W Main St 1st Floor

        Watertown, NY 13601

      • White Plains Office

        151 E Post Rd Suite 103

        White Plains, NY 10601

      • Yonkers Office

        94 School Street Second Floor Suite # 3

        Yonkers, NY 10701

    • Ohio
      • Cleveland Office

        9605 Lorain Ave

        Cleveland, OH 44102

      • Columbus Office

        585 S Front St. #230

        Columbus, OH 43215

    • Pennsylvania
      • Allentown Office

        3037 Pike Ave

        Allentown, PA 18104

      • Altoona Office

        1216 11th Ave

        Altoona, PA 16601

      • Bethlehem Office

        3005 Brodhead Rd Suite 101

        Bethlehem, PA 18020

      • Blue Bell Office

        725 Skippack Pike

        Blue Bell, PA 19422

      • Carlisle Office

        109 W Louther St

        Carlisle, PA 17013

      • Chester Office

        400 Welsh St 2nd Fl

        Chester, PA 19013

      • Easton Office

        1733 Washington Blvd

        Easton, PA 18042

      • Erie Office

        3800 W 12th St. Suite 6

        Erie, PA 16505

      • Harrisburg Office

        415 Market St. Suite# 204A

        Harrisburg, PA 17101

      • Lancaster Office

        3543 Marietta Ave. Unit H2

        Lancaster, PA 17601

      • Lansdale Office

        100 W Main St. Suite 502

        Lansdale, PA 19446

      • Leola Office

        4 Keystone Ct Suite# 40

        Leola, PA 17540

      • Philadelphia Office

        110 S 20th St

        Philadelphia, PA 19103

      • Pittsburgh Office

        1546 Fulton St #301

        Pittsburgh, PA 15233

      • Pittsburgh Office

        5001 Baum Blvd Suite # 795

        Pittsburgh, PA 15213

      • Reading Office

        243 S 5th St

        Reading, PA 19602

      • Scranton Office

        1150 S Main Ave #210

        Scranton, PA 18504

      • State College Office

        522 E College Ave Suite WS#1, 2nd Fl

        State College, PA 16801

      • Upper Darby Office

        8600 West Chester Pike #100

        Upper Darby Township, PA 19082

      • Wilkes-Barre Office

        780 Hazle St Front

        Wilkes-Barre, PA 18706

      • York Office

        2217 Carlisle Rd #407

        York, PA 17408

    • Vermont
      • Rutland Office

        734 US-4

        Rutland, VT 05701

  • Services
    • Personal Injury Lawyer
    • Car Accidents
    • Construction Work Injuries
    • Semi-Truck Accidents
    • Dog Bites
    • Slip & Fall Cases
    • Workers Compensation
  • About Us
  • Our Blog
  • Attorneys
  • Careers
  • Internship
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Results
  • Testimonials
  • Glossary
Ask us anything

Can Lack of Informed Consent Be Medical Malpractice in Ohio?

Learn when a lack of informed consent is medical malpractice in Ohio, what evidence can prove your claim, and how long you have to file after a medical injury.

Request a Free Consultation
  1. News
  2. Ohio
  3. Can Lack of Informed Consent Be Medical Malpractice in Ohio?

You agreed to surgery because you expected it to relieve your pain. Months later, you have weakness that makes it difficult to work, and a second specialist tells you it was a known risk of the procedure. You remember signing a consent form, but you don’t remember anyone discussing that complication. Does your signature settle the matter?

Yes, a lack of informed consent can be medical malpractice in Ohio, even when a procedure was performed competently. The claim turns on whether the physician failed to disclose and discuss a material risk, whether that risk occurred and caused your injury, and whether a reasonable person in your position would have declined the treatment if properly informed. A signed form can carry substantial weight, so the strength of the case often depends on the exact language of the form and what the medical evidence shows.

Key Takeaways: Can Lack of Informed Consent Be Medical Malpractice in Ohio?

  • Ohio recognizes lack of informed consent as a medical malpractice claim.
  • A qualifying written consent form is presumed valid under Ohio law.
  • Medical expert testimony is required to establish the relevant risks and connect the undisclosed risk to the injury.
  • Ohio asks what a reasonable patient in your position would have decided after proper disclosure.
  • Most Ohio medical malpractice claims must be filed within one year of when the claim accrues.

When Can Lack of Informed Consent Amount to Medical Malpractice?

The first question an attorney will ask is what you wish you had known before agreeing to treatment. “I didn’t know recovery would be this hard” describes a real experience, but it leaves the legal issue open. “I was told I could expect temporary numbness, and nobody discussed the risk of permanent weakness” identifies a specific difference an attorney and a medical expert can investigate. The distinction matters when a broad warning describes a complication in terms that may understate its consequences.

In Nickell v. Gonzalez, 17 Ohio St.3d 136 (1985), the Supreme Court of Ohio tied the duty to disclose to risks a reasonable patient would consider significant in deciding whether to proceed. That inquiry takes account of the patient’s condition as the physician knew or should have known it to be. A small risk of lasting loss of hand function can carry particular weight for someone who has already limited use of the other hand. The likelihood of a complication matters alongside its severity and the expected benefit of treatment.

What Disclosure Standard Applies to an Ohio Physician?

The medical expert and the jury answer different questions. Under White v. Leimbach, 2011-Ohio-6238, expert testimony establishes the medical risks associated with the procedure. Once those risks are established, the jury or judge deciding the facts determines which risks would have mattered to a reasonable patient in the circumstances. An expert can explain why prior surgery or an underlying condition made a complication medically significant. The patient’s testimony and the consultation records can then help establish what the physician actually said about it.

Expect the defense to start with the signed form. Ohio Revised Code § 2317.54 states that informed consent to a surgical or medical procedure, or a course of procedures, gives qualifying written consent a presumption of validity. To qualify, the form must meet statutory requirements concerning the procedure, its purpose and expected result, reasonably known risks, acknowledgment of disclosure and answers to questions, and an authorized signature. Outside emergencies, it must also name the physicians who will perform the intended surgery. If the form qualifies, Ohio law limits challenges to it and specifies grounds such as bad faith, material fraud, or an inability to communicate effectively in the language of the form.

How Do You Prove That an Undisclosed Risk Caused Additional Harm?

Start with what changed after treatment. If a patient had weakness before surgery and it worsened afterward, the timing alone leaves several explanations open. The defense may argue that the underlying disease progressed or that a separate event caused the decline. A medical expert can compare preoperative exams with postoperative findings to determine whether the specific risk at issue materialized and caused the new or worsened impairment.

The next question is whether a reasonable person in the patient’s position would have declined the proposed treatment after hearing the warning. A viable alternative can make that argument stronger. If symptoms were stable and continued therapy was still a reasonable option, the patient had a meaningful choice. If delaying treatment carried a substantial risk of permanent damage, the defense has a stronger argument that a reasonable patient would have proceeded despite the warning.

Both questions affect what an insurer may be willing to pay. A patient may have needed some rehabilitation because of the original condition, regardless of the procedure. Records showing that the complication required additional surgery, prolonged time away from work, or created a lasting need for assistance help separate those losses from the care the patient already needed. That distinction gives both sides a more concrete basis for evaluating compensation.

Which Providers or Facilities May Be Liable?

The name on the hospital bill may tell you little about who was responsible for the consent discussion. A surgeon may have recommended the procedure, while an anesthesiologist discussed a separate set of risks. An attorney compares the consultation notes, procedure records, and consent documents to identify who was responsible for disclosing the particular risk that caused the injury.

Ohio also limits when a hospital or ambulatory surgical facility can be liable for a physician’s failure to obtain informed consent. Under the statute, the facility can be held liable for that failure only if the physician was its employee. A physician’s privileges to operate at a hospital and the physician’s employment status are separate questions. Employment records and practice agreements can therefore matter as much to identifying the proper defendant as the name printed on the consent form.

Medical Evidence That Shows What You Were Told

An attorney reviewing a disputed consent conversation will compare records from before and after the procedure. Three sets of records help establish what information was available to you when you made your decision and what happened afterward.

  1. Consultation notes and portal messages. These can show which alternatives were medically available, what questions you asked, and whether you had expressed a preference to wait or pursue a different treatment.
  2. The signed form and any materials provided with it. Procedure-specific language, handwritten entries, and interpreter records can help show how the risks were communicated. An unsigned sample form says less about the conversation than the actual version you received.
  3. Baseline exams and follow-up records. Preoperative findings establish how you were functioning before treatment. Subsequent imaging, specialist evaluations, and therapy notes help an expert assess when the impairment appeared, what caused it, and whether it is likely to last.

Frequently Asked Questions About Lack of Informed Consent Claims in Ohio

Does a Bad Outcome Automatically Mean Malpractice?

No. A properly disclosed complication can occur despite appropriate care. An attorney reviewing the records will consider separately whether the provider performed the procedure negligently and whether the physician failed to discuss a material risk before obtaining consent. A patient who accepted a known risk may still have a claim if negligent care caused the injury.

What Deadline Applies to This Type of Medical Malpractice Claim?

Medical malpractice actions generally give you one year from the date the claim accrues. Ohio courts typically look to the later of when you discovered or reasonably should have discovered the injury and when the physician-patient relationship ended for the condition at issue. A second opinion can help explain the injury, but the filing period may already be running if earlier events reasonably put you on notice.

If you give the required written notice before the one-year filing period expires, Ohio Revised Code § 2305.113(B) allows you to file a medical malpractice lawsuit against the notified party within 180 days after notice is given. For a medical claim, you must send the notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to an address authorized by the statute, such as the provider’s residence, professional practice, employer, or business address on file with the appropriate licensing agency. The notice must be properly delivered to take effect, so mailing it before the deadline does not necessarily mean it was timely given. Ohio also generally bars medical claims filed more than four years after the alleged act or omission, subject to limited exceptions. These deadlines can run while you are still gathering records or seeking follow-up care, so the dates should be reviewed early.

Filing the lawsuit also involves an important requirement. Under Ohio Civil Rule 10(D)(2), a medical malpractice complaint must include an affidavit of merit from a qualified medical expert when expert testimony is necessary to establish liability. The affidavit provides preliminary medical support for the claim. If it is not ready when the lawsuit is filed, the plaintiff can request additional time by filing a motion with the complaint. Because informed consent claims require expert testimony about the undisclosed risks and resulting injury, obtaining expert support early is an important part of preparing the case.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, Is Just One Phone Call Away

If you learned about a serious risk only after it happened, the consent paperwork is one part of the story. Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, can review the records with you, identify what a medical expert would need to evaluate, and assess which losses may be tied to the complication. An early review can also help determine who was responsible for the disclosure and how much time you have to pursue an Ohio medical malpractice claim.

Contact us today for a free legal consultation.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult an attorney for advice regarding your specific situation.
Share:
Most Popular
Can Lack of Informed Consent Be Medical Malpractice in Ohio?
Can You File a Medical Malpractice Claim for a Birth Injury in Ohio?
Understanding Ohio Workers’ Compensation Benefits for Occupational Diseases
Motorcycle Accident Claim Denied in Ohio? What to Do Next
How Ohio Personal Injury Settlements Are Calculated
Recent Posts
Can Lack of Informed Consent Be Medical Malpractice in Ohio?
Can You File a Medical Malpractice Claim for a Birth Injury in Ohio?
How Are Workers’ Comp Settlements Calculated in Ohio?
How Ohio Personal Injury Settlements Are Calculated
Who Receives the Money From a Wrongful Death Settlement in Ohio?

Still have questions?

Speak to an attorney today

Call now and be done

(201) 853-1505

Contact Us

Cleveland Office
9605 Lorain Ave
Cleveland, OH 44102
View on Map
Columbus Office
585 S Front St. #230
Columbus, OH 43215
View on Map
Injuries Category
We aim to respond as quickly as possible, but allow 1 to 2 working days for a reply.
Footer map image
Brandon J. Broderick
At Brandon J. Broderick, Personal Injury Attorney At Law, we are devoted to helping injured individuals and their family members
(877) 448-7350
Services
  • Personal Injury
  • Covid-19
  • Workers’ Injuries
  • Car Accident
  • Employment Law
  • Menu
  • About Us
  • Our Blog
  • Attorneys
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Homepage
  • Locations
  • Results
  • Testimonials
  • We serve the following localities: Paramus, Jersey City, Trenton, Atlantic City, Cherry Hill, Edison, Millburn, Asbury Park, Vineland, Bordentown, River Edge, Camden, Newark, Elizabeth, Clifton, West Hempstead, Schenectady, New Rochelle, Huntington, Rochester, Elmira, Middletown, East Islip, Newburgh, Binghamton, Buffalo, Yonkers, White Plains, Danbury, Norwalk, Stamford, Hartford, New Haven, Bridgeport, Milford, Norwich, Pinellas Park, Jacksonville, Rutland, Easton, Allentown, Harrisburg, Lancaster, Erie, Leola, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Lansdale, Bethlehem, Scranton, Worcester, Fall River, New Bedford, Springfield, Louisville, Cleveland, Columbus, Toms River, Parsippany, Paterson, Ewing, Brooklyn, New York, Albany, Staten Island, Utica, Syracuse, Queens, Bronx, Mount Vernon, Waterbury, Reading, Boston, Upper Darby Township, Altoona, Montclair, Woodbridge, Morristown, Bayonne, New Brunswick, Irvington, Brick Township, Flushing, Long Island City, Poughkeepsie, Amherst, Saratoga Springs, Princeton, State College, York, Ithaca, Cheektowaga, Quincy, Carlisle, Plattsburgh, Chester, Watertown, Cambridge, Groton, Somerville, Hamburg, Hackensack, Mount Laurel, Blue Bell, Connecticut, New Jersey, Bergen County, Essex County, Middlesex County, Hudson County, Passaic County, Morris County, Union County, Somerset County, Monmouth County, Mercer County, Camden County, New York County, Kings County, Queens County, Westchester County, Rockland County, Fairfield County, Troy, Morris Town, Manhattan.
    Car Accident Attorney • Truck Accident Attorney • Motorcycle Accident Attorney • Slip & Fall Attorney • Personal Injury Attorney
    Attorney Advertising. Prior Results Do Not Guarantee A Similar Outcome. © 2026 Brandon J. Broderick LLC D/B/A Brandon J. Broderick, Personal Injury Attorney at Law
    Privacy Policy Sitemap