If you hurt your back lifting equipment at work, you generally don’t have to prove your employer did anything wrong to get New Jersey workers’ comp benefits. You could still qualify even if you lifted awkwardly or lost your footing.

New Jersey workers’ compensation is a no-fault system. To qualify, you need to show that you’re a covered employee and that your injury happened in the course of your job and was related to your work. Medical records can help show what treatment you need and how the injury affects your ability to work.

Key Takeaways About Proving Fault in a New Jersey Workers’ Comp Claim

  • You generally don’t have to prove that your employer or a coworker caused your injury. An ordinary mistake on your part generally won’t cost you your benefits or reduce the amount you receive.
  • The evidence needs to connect your injury to your work and support the benefits you’re asking for.
  • New Jersey law recognizes limited defenses. For example, an employer relying on intoxication must prove it was the sole cause of the injury.
  • Report a workplace accident as soon as possible. The deadline for notifying your employer is separate from the deadline for filing a formal claim petition.
  • If someone outside your employer’s business is legally responsible for your injury, you may also have a separate claim. Your share of fault can affect what you recover in a negligence lawsuit.

How Does New Jersey’s No-Fault Workers’ Comp System Work?

Under N.J.S.A. 34:15-7, workers’ compensation generally covers qualifying work injuries regardless of whether your employer was negligent. You can have a valid claim even if your employer followed every safety rule. Evidence of an unsafe condition can still help explain how you were injured or identify an outside company that may be responsible.

New Jersey workers’ comp can pay for reasonable and necessary medical care, temporary disability benefits, and qualifying permanent disability. Workers’ comp does not include a separate award for pain and suffering. If you receive a permanent partial disability award, the percentage reflects the extent of your disability.

What Do You Have to Prove for New Jersey Workers’ Comp Benefits?

Start with what you were doing when you got hurt. If your shoulder started hurting while you were moving inventory, your incident report and medical records can help establish when the pain began, what you were lifting, and how the injury is related to that task. If you were commuting, running a personal errand, or attending a work social event, whether you were on the clock may tell only part of the story. What you were doing, where it happened, and whether your employer directed the activity can all matter.

A preexisting condition can still be part of a valid claim. If you already had shoulder pain and lifting at work made it worse, your medical records can help show what changed. You might have new symptoms or trouble doing tasks you could handle before the injury.

The evidence also depends on the benefit you’re seeking. Medical records can explain why you need treatment. Work restrictions and pay records can help support a claim for temporary disability benefits. For permanent partial disability benefits, objective medical findings must show a lasting limitation that meaningfully affects your ability to work or substantially interferes with everyday activities. You may still qualify even if you return to work at the same pay.

Can a Mistake at Work Cost You Workers’ Comp Benefits?

If you lifted a box awkwardly, rushed through a task, or missed a hazard, you can still qualify for workers’ comp. A supervisor’s comment that you should have been more careful, or a write-up about the incident, does not by itself establish grounds to deny benefits.

New Jersey law does exclude intentionally self-inflicted injuries. It also recognizes defenses involving intoxication, unlawful use of controlled substances, and deliberate failure to use required protective equipment in certain circumstances.

For the protective-equipment defense to apply, the employer must show it provided suitable equipment, clearly required employees to use it, and consistently enforced that rule. It must also document that you deliberately failed to use the equipment properly despite repeated warnings and show that this failure caused the injury. The defense does not apply if immediate danger or the need to act right away left you unable to use the equipment properly.

In Tlumac v. High Bridge Stone, the New Jersey Supreme Court held that the employer must prove intoxication was the sole cause of the injury. If another factor also contributed to the injury, the employer cannot use the intoxication defense to bar benefits.

Preserve Evidence That Shows How You Were Hurt

A witness who saw you get hurt or a camera that recorded the accident can help if the insurer questions what happened. If symptoms developed gradually, tell your employer and your medical provider when you first noticed them and which tasks seemed to make them worse.

  1. Report the injury promptly. Describe what you were doing, where and when it happened, what hurts, and who saw it.
  2. Save any incident reports, photos, schedules, messages, and witness contact information you have access to.
  3. Ask promptly for relevant surveillance footage or electronic records to be preserved. Some systems record over older files.
  4. Keep copies of treatment records, work restrictions, wage records, and messages about authorized care or modified duties.

After a workplace accident, you can generally lose your right to benefits if no one reports the injury to your employer and your employer does not otherwise learn about it within 90 days. Even a shorter delay can affect your claim, so report the injury as soon as you can.

Ask your employer how to get treatment. In New Jersey, your employer or its insurance carrier generally selects the treating doctor. Exceptions can apply in an emergency or when the employer improperly refuses or fails to provide necessary care. Getting treatment on your own in other circumstances can lead to a dispute over who pays.

What if the Insurer Denies Your Claim or Disputes Your Benefits?

Find out what the insurer is disputing. If it says the accident didn’t happen at work, witness statements or an incident report may help. If it agrees you were injured at work but questions whether you need further treatment or still have work restrictions, your medical records may be more important.

You can file a formal claim petition or request an informal hearing with the New Jersey Division of Workers’ Compensation. An informal hearing gives the parties a chance to resolve a dispute, but the judge’s recommendations are nonbinding. If you need prompt treatment or temporary disability payments, you may be able to file a motion asking a workers’ compensation judge to address those benefits.

For a workplace accident, you generally have two years to file a formal claim petition from the date of the accident or the last payment of compensation, whichever is later. Medical treatment authorized by your employer generally counts as a payment of compensation and can affect when your petition is due. For a work-related illness, the two-year period generally starts when you first know the nature of your disabling condition and that it’s related to your work. Requesting an informal hearing does not pause the filing deadline.

When Does Fault Matter in a Third-Party Lawsuit?

Workers’ comp is generally your remedy against your employer for a work injury. New Jersey recognizes a narrow exception for an employer’s intentional wrong. If someone outside your employer’s business, such as another driver, a contractor, or an equipment manufacturer, is legally responsible for your injury, you may have a separate third-party claim. That claim may allow you to recover damages such as pain and suffering.

In a negligence lawsuit, New Jersey’s comparative negligence rule reduces your damages by your share of fault. You can’t recover if your share is greater than the fault of the defendant or the combined fault of the defendants you seek to recover from. For example, if your damages total $100,000 and you’re found 20% at fault, that finding would reduce your damages to $80,000. If the case goes to trial, the judge or jury decides how to assign fault.

Your employer or its workers’ comp insurer may also be entitled to repayment from a third-party settlement or judgment for benefits it already paid. That can affect how much you keep from the third-party recovery.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law Is One Phone Call Away

If your employer says you caused your own injury or the insurer is disputing your treatment or benefits, Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law can review what happened, explain your options, and help you determine whether you may also have a claim against a third party.

Our team is available 24/7 for a free consultation. Contact us today.


This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult an attorney for advice regarding your specific situation.

Still have questions?

Speak to an attorney today

Call now and be done