Traffic slows in a downpour, but the driver behind you keeps coming. After the crash, the driver says their wipers were streaking and they could barely see your brake lights.
Faulty windshield wipers can affect who’s at fault in a New Jersey car accident claim. They can help show negligence if the driver or vehicle owner failed to use reasonable care and the poor visibility contributed to the crash. If you’re found partly at fault because faulty wipers on your own vehicle limited your view and contributed to the crash, your compensation can be reduced. In either case, the timing matters. Could the driver have seen traffic slowing soon enough to brake or avoid the collision if the windshield had been clear?
Key Takeaways: Driving With Faulty Windshield Wipers in New Jersey
- New Jersey requires motor vehicles with windshields to have working equipment the driver can use to clear rain, snow, or other moisture and see the road ahead.
- A proven wiper violation can support a negligence claim when poor visibility contributed to the collision.
- Prior complaints about streaking or wipers that stop and start can help show that the driver or owner had reason to address the problem.
- If you’re found partly at fault for the crash, your share of fault can reduce your compensation. You can still recover at 50 percent fault, but more than 50 percent bars recovery on the negligence claim.
- If your vehicle is being repaired, ask the shop to save any wiper parts it replaces. Request a copy of any original video before it’s overwritten.
When Does New Jersey Law Require Working Windshield Wipers?
The requirement applies even when the forecast is clear. Under N.J.S.A. 39:3-74, every motor vehicle with a windshield must have at least one working device the driver can control to clear rain, snow, or other moisture and provide a clear view. A wiper arm can move across the glass while a torn blade leaves a band of water directly in front of the driver. In a crash claim, what matters is how well the wiper cleared the driver’s view.
New Jersey’s vehicle inspection standards also say that both wipers must work if the vehicle was built with two (N.J.A.C. 13:20-32.10(b)). If the driver-side wiper failed and the passenger-side wiper still worked, examining both wipers can help show how much of the windshield was clear and what the driver could see before the crash.
Can Defective or Inadequate Wipers Help Prove Negligence?
Evidence that the problem was noticeable before the crash can help show that someone had a chance to address it. A service invoice might show that the owner reported wipers that sometimes stopped mid-sweep. A passenger might recall the wipers stalling again at the start of the trip. The invoice helps show what the owner knew, and the passenger’s account helps establish when the driver may have noticed the problem.
New Jersey’s model civil jury instructions explain that a jury can consider a proven motor vehicle violation along with the other evidence when deciding whether someone was negligent. For a claim against the vehicle owner over a mechanical defect, the jury can also consider whether the owner knew about the defect or could have discovered it through reasonable care.
With a borrowed car or a work van, the driver and the person responsible for maintenance may have known about the problem at different times. A complaint sent to a fleet manager could show that the company had a chance to repair the wipers before the trip. If the driver first noticed the problem on the road, the question is how they responded once their view began to deteriorate.
How Do You Connect Poor Visibility to the Cause of the Crash?
Suppose traffic ahead had been stopped for several seconds, the road was straight, and video shows the driver braking only just before impact. If the wipers were leaving a smear at eye level and the driver said they saw the stopped car too late, those details can help explain the delay. A crash reconstruction expert may be able to use the video timing, vehicle speed, and wet-road stopping distance to estimate whether braking earlier could have prevented the crash or made the impact less severe.
If a vehicle pulled into the lane a moment before the collision, the following driver may have had too little room to stop even with a clear windshield. Evidence may also point to distraction or excessive speed. More than one factor can contribute to the same crash. Video and witness accounts can help establish when the hazard appeared and when the driver reacted.
Can Weather Conditions or Another Driver’s Conduct Affect Fault?
A downpour changes what safe driving looks like. The posted speed may be too fast when visibility is poor, and a gap that gives a driver enough room to stop on dry pavement may be too short on a wet road. A driver with faulty wipers may share fault for failing to slow down as visibility worsened. Another driver may also share fault for changing lanes unsafely or following too closely for the conditions.
Under New Jersey’s Comparative Negligence Act, N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1, your compensation is reduced by your share of fault if you’re eligible to recover. If you’re seeking compensation from one party, you can recover only if your share of fault is equal to or less than theirs. If you’re seeking compensation from more than one party, your share is compared with their combined share of fault. For example, if your damages are assessed at $100,000 and you’re found 20 percent at fault, the fault reduction brings that amount to $80,000.
What Evidence Can Show Whether Faulty Wipers Contributed to a Crash?
A body shop may replace the wiper assembly, a tow yard may release the car for salvage, and a nearby business may record over its footage. These details can help establish what the driver could see before the crash and whether the impact itself damaged the wipers.
- Vehicle condition and service records. Photograph the blades, arms, and windshield before repairs if you have access to the vehicle. Save invoices and inspection notes, and ask the shop to keep any wiper parts it replaces. A mechanic may be able to tell the difference between longstanding wear and a wiper arm bent by the collision.
- Local weather records. Match radar and nearby observations to the crash time and location. An airport weather report may show that rain was falling in the area, while video from the scene may give a better sense of how much rain and spray drivers encountered.
- Original video. Request the full clip, including the seconds leading up to the crash. Those seconds may show when brake lights came on or whether the wipers paused. A camera mounted high on the windshield may have had a different view than the driver.
- Driver and witness statements. Write down what people said and when they said it. A driver who says “I couldn’t see” could be describing heavy rain, road spray, or a wiper failure. A witness who recalls the driver trying the wiper switch repeatedly before the crash can help establish when the problem started.
Frequently Asked Questions About Windshield Wiper Violations and Car Accident Claims in New Jersey
Does a wiper-related traffic citation prove liability?
A wiper-related ticket is an allegation. What the officer actually saw or documented may be more useful to your claim, such as a photograph of a missing blade or notes from testing the wipers. If the officer first examined the equipment after a front-end impact, there may still be a dispute about when it broke. You can still have a claim if no ticket was issued. The evidence needs to show that someone’s negligence contributed to the crash and that the crash caused your injuries.
What if the wipers failed suddenly during the storm?
If the wipers failed without warning, it may be harder to show that the driver or owner should have discovered the defect beforehand. How the driver responded still matters. If the wipers stopped just before impact, the driver may have had little time to react. If the driver kept going past a safe place to pull over, that decision could affect who’s at fault.
Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away
A New Jersey car accident claim can turn on what a driver could see in the seconds before impact. Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law can help preserve evidence, investigate whether faulty wipers contributed to the collision, and challenge an insurer’s attempt to assign you an unfair share of fault.
Our team is available 24/7, and we offer a free consultation. Contact us today.