Car accidents can trigger a wave of confusion and stress, especially in the moments following a collision. Amid the flurry of exchanging information, contacting insurance, and assessing damages, one question often comes up: Should you obtain a police report? The answer depends on the nature and severity of the crash, but securing an official record can often play a huge role in protecting your legal rights and strengthening any future claims.

Why a Police Report Matters After Car Accidents

A police report serves as an objective record of the accident. Compiled by law enforcement officers who respond to the scene, it documents key details such as:

• Time, date, and location of the accident
• Identifying information for all parties involved
• Witness statements
• Preliminary assessment of fault or contributing factors
• Diagrams or photographs of the scene (in many cases)
• Notes on any traffic violations or criminal activity

This document becomes a foundational piece of evidence when dealing with insurance companies or pursuing legal action. Without it, establishing facts or proving liability becomes significantly more challenging.

When You Must Contact the Police After a Car Accident

While not every minor fender bender requires a police report, there are clear circumstances where calling the police is legally required or highly advisable. State laws vary slightly, but in general, you should contact law enforcement immediately if:

• Someone is injured or killed: Even minor injuries can escalate, and a police report is essential in documenting the incident.
• Property damage exceeds a certain threshold: In many states, this amount ranges from $500 to $1,000. If the damage appears significant, it’s better to err on the side of caution.
• The accident involves a hit-and-run: A police report is needed to pursue legal action against the fleeing driver.
• One or more drivers appear intoxicated: Police must document suspected impairment.
• There is a dispute over what happened: A neutral third-party report can be invaluable if conflicting accounts arise later.

Failing to contact the police when legally required to do so can result in fines or penalties and may harm your ability to file an insurance claim.

Minor Car Accident? When It’s Still Smart to Get a Report

Even when the law doesn’t explicitly require it, obtaining a police report is often in your best interest. Here’s why:

• Minor damage can lead to hidden costs: Mechanical issues or medical symptoms may not surface until days after the collision.
• Insurance disputes are common: Insurers frequently scrutinize claims, especially when damages are not clearly documented at the time of the accident.
• Fraud prevention: A police report provides an official record that can deter exaggerated or false claims by the other party.

If police will not come to the scene of a minor accident, many departments allow drivers to file a report at the station or online within a designated timeframe.

Time Limits for Filing a Police Report After a Car Accident

Each state imposes its own deadlines for filing an accident report. These deadlines typically range from 24 hours to 10 days. Some examples:

• New York: Drivers must file a report within 10 days if property damage exceeds $1,000 or if there is injury or death.
• Florida: Reports are required within 10 days for accidents involving injury, death, or property damage above $500.
• Massachusetts: If damage exceeds $1,000 or injury occurs, drivers must file a report within five days.

Failing to meet these reporting deadlines can lead to fines and may also complicate your insurance claim.

How to Obtain a Copy of a Car Accident Police Report

The process for obtaining a police report depends on the responding agency. In general:

• Local police or sheriff’s department: You can request a copy directly from the department, usually in person or through an online portal.
• State highway patrol: If the accident occurred on a highway or state-maintained road, contact the appropriate state agency.
• Insurance companies: Many insurers will obtain the report on your behalf once you initiate a claim.

Reports typically become available within a few business days of the accident. Fees may apply, usually between $5 and $25.

What if the Police Didn’t Come to the Scene of Your Car Accident?

In minor accidents, police may not respond in person—especially in jurisdictions with limited resources. If this happens, you should:

• Document the scene yourself: Take photographs of vehicle damage, skid marks, road conditions, traffic signs, and injuries.
• Gather witness information: Record names and contact details of anyone who saw the accident.
• Exchange full information with the other driver: This includes driver’s license numbers, insurance details, and vehicle registration.
• File a report independently: Many police departments allow or require self-reporting for minor crashes.

Your personal documentation, combined with any self-filed police report, can still provide valuable evidence for your insurance claim or potential lawsuit.

How a Police Report Strengthens Legal Claims

When pursuing compensation for injuries or damages—either through an insurance claim or a personal injury lawsuit—a police report can serve several key purposes:

• Establishes a timeline: The report documents when and where the accident occurred, providing an official record that supports your account.
• Preserves witness statements: Witnesses often forget details over time; statements included in the report capture their observations while fresh.
• Supports fault determination: While not legally binding, an officer’s notes on violations or contributing factors carry weight with insurers and courts.
• Counters false claims: In the absence of an official report, the other party could later present a conflicting or exaggerated version of events.

For these reasons, personal injury attorneys typically advise clients to obtain and preserve the police report as part of their claim preparation.

Conclusion

Getting a police report after a car accident is often one of the smartest steps you can take to protect your legal and financial interests. In serious accidents, it’s required by law. In minor incidents, it still serves as a valuable safeguard against future complications. Whether you’re filing an insurance claim or considering legal action, this official document can provide the clarity and credibility needed to support your case.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating car accident claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.

Contact us now for a free legal review.